We Connect Asia

SAF

Feedstock Price Indexation and Pass-Through: Four Mechanisms and What Each Does to Risk

10 min read  ·  Dec 2, 2025  ·  By Alex

feedstock price indexation

There is no published benchmark for sustainable aviation fuel, so I pass the main input cost through one of four published routes: an aviation fuel index plus an agreed premium, a fixed contractual price, a cost-of-production assessment, or a cost-plus model that moves with the inputs. Here feedstock means the oils, fats and residues a plant buys, and an index means a benchmark price published by a price reporting agency, a firm that reports assessed prices for a market. It decides which line moves and which absorbs. That is the core of feedstock price indexation at pre-FID, and I read it beside the Southeast Asia feedstock availability picture.

A pass-through is the contract clause that carries a movement in input cost into the sale price, so the model shows one line that moves and one that absorbs it. The four routes below come from published contract menus, and each leaves a different party holding the movement.

In short

  • No index: with none published, lenders fall back on a fixed cost basis or a commodity index they know (Dentons).
  • Composition: production cost plus market premium, logistics, certification, transaction costs and chain markups.
  • Biggest line: feedstock is the largest cost component for a HEFA producer, hydrogen leads variable cost.
  • Four routes: index plus premium, fixed price, cost-of-production, cost-plus.
  • Clause: transparency provisions and a diversified feedstock mix close the open risk.
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

In this article

The problem in one sentence

In the absence of any well-established pricing index for SAF, project finance lenders will likely require offtake to be on a fixed-cost basis or by reference to another commodity index with which lenders are familiar and comfortable.

The reason that index does not exist yet is published: the long-term valuation of SAF is currently impossible as the premium for SAF is too uncertain to establish a reliable value, and the SAF price will be a function of demand, largely driven by regulatory drivers, and supply which combines feedstock costs and production costs.

That is the sentence I put on top of the model. I cannot quote a long-term SAF price, so I quote a mechanism instead, and I show which line in the model moves when the input moves. A pricing tab built on a number nobody publishes is a tab a lender will strike through at the first review.

What this means for you: write one sentence at the top of your model that names the mechanism, not the price, because the mechanism is the part a lender can underwrite.

What the SAF price is made of

The price that airlines pay for SAF, in addition to the production costs, incorporates add-on costs such as a market premium, logistics, certification, transaction-related costs, and markups throughout the supply chain. That list is the structure of the SAF price I am modeling, and each item gets its own line.

The size of one of those add-ons is published: in 2024, the difference between production cost and market prices, the market premium, in Europe reached as high as around 1000 USD/tonne of HEFA SAF, while SAF prices fluctuated throughout the year and the market lacks transparency in terms of deals and prices paid.

The premium is visible at the buyer’s end too: airlines paid a premium of USD 2.9 billion for the 1.9 Mt of SAF available in 2025, of which USD 1.4 billion reflects the standard SAF price premium over conventional aviation fuel, or CAF. I keep the premium on its own line, separate from feedstock.

What this means for you: name the premium as its own line and let it sit outside the feedstock formula.

Feedstock is the biggest line

Feedstock costs are the largest cost component for a HEFA producer, and hydrogen is the largest cost component within the variable processing costs (IATA, 12 May 2024). The same point is made from the production side: feedstock accounts for the lion’s share of total HEFA production costs, and the price of the feedstock can vary significantly with market supply and demand dynamics.

The base cost is above the incumbent: HEFA, the hydrotreated esters and fatty acids route, offers the lowest levelized cost compared to other pathways, with costs currently 2 to 2.5 times that of conventional aviation fuel.

Because that line moves with the market, every pricing mechanism below is really an argument about who absorbs the movement. When I structure the feedstock supply side, I name the sources, the formula, and the limit on how far the formula can travel.

What this means for you: size the feedstock line first, then let the pricing mechanism follow it, because everything else in the model hangs off that one number.

The four mechanisms, and what each one does

The published menu is short: near-term supply, one-off or annual contract, priced on a CAF index or a SAF index; long-term offtake agreements priced on cost-of-production or cost-plus; and an equity stake with unspecified pricing. Where no index fits, lenders fall back on a fixed-cost basis.

With an index plus a premium, the agreed SAF price is a published CAF price index plus an agreed premium, which lets the buyer extend its ongoing fuel price hedging to SAF, though the premium is often higher than under long-term offtake pricing.

Cost-of-production is a price reporting agency assessment built from assessed feedstock prices and related costs at the refinery gate. Cost-plus forecasts total costs of feedstock, hydrogen, variable cost, fixed costs, CAPEX and OPEX, deducts rebates, and leaves the green premium, meaning the extra paid above the fossil reference, passing feedstock and hydrogen fluctuation from seller to buyer. The indices themselves come from a price reporting agency such as Argus or S&P Global Commodity Insights.

What this means for you: choose one route, name the party that absorbs the movement, and show both on the same tab.

Mandates move the demand side of the index

The demand the index reflects is policy made: in 2025 SAF output is expected to reach 1.9 million tonnes, double the 1 Mt produced in 2024, representing only 0.6% of total jet fuel consumption, rising to 2.4 Mt and 0.8% in 2026.

Mandates bite on price: the UK SAF mandate has triggered price spikes, leaving airlines to absorb the burden, and under ReFuelEU Aviation airlines pay up to five times more than the price of conventional jet fuel.

The pull on the feedstock side is equally published: Europe consumes 130,000 barrels of used cooking oil a day, 8 times more than it collects, global airlines are set to triple demand for UCO by 2030, collecting UCO in Asia is around 30% cheaper than in Europe, and more than 80% of current SAF volumes are being produced from UCO (Transport and Environment, 18 June 2024). That demand curve is written by legislation in several regions at once, not by a clearing house.

What this means for you: forecast the mandate before the price, because the mandate is what sets both the SAF demand and the feedstock bid underneath it.

What a lender will actually sign

A lender reads the index against the debt: investors often require at least 70 to 80 percent of annual capacity to be covered by offtake agreements, some lenders require 100 percent of the SAF produced to have reliable offtake covering the full loan tenor, and the offtake contract needs to cover the tenure of debt financing, 8 to 14 years (World Economic Forum, February 2025).

Lenders treat merchant exposure the same way: lenders will be reluctant to take significant merchant exposure for a new sector, and any limited merchant strategy will need detailed marketing analysis and considered implications for debt-sizing.

The scale behind those decisions is counted: by 2030 demand for global SAF is expected to reach 17 million tonnes per annum, installed capacity reached 4.4 Mt by end 2024 with 6.9 Mt of expansion planned, and the industry may require between 19 billion and 45 billion US dollars of capital expenditure by 2030 (World Economic Forum).

Every one of those numbers assumes a price line that holds for the whole tenor.

What this means for you: cover the tenor you are asking for, because a price line that stops before the debt stops is not a price line at all.

The pass-through clause itself

The clause decides who pays: in cost-of-production and cost-plus models, more risk is passed to the buyer who would absorb variations in feedstock price or other operational costs incurred by the producer.

Left open, the clause becomes the risk: clauses that allow the seller to renegotiate pricing mid-contract or even yearly, if uncapped, can add complexity to the fuel budget and another layer of risk to supply.

Two published answers close it: any contract should include strong transparency provisions regarding fluctuating costs, and diversifying feedstock usage in contracts could be another way to mitigate the fluctuation risk, with the latest version of the Aviation Fuel Supply Model Agreement setting out SAF clauses to protect buyers.

Change in law sits in the same clause: ideally the costs of compliance with tightened SAF regulatory requirements are passed to the offtaker under the offtake contract.

What this means for you: cap the renegotiation right, define the transparency you will actually deliver, and put the change in law cost on the same page.

How I would run this if it were my file

I write the index question as a policy question first, since policy uncertainty covers the requirement for stable long-term legislation through mandated volumes and incentives, regulatory oversight to certify emerging technology and define lifecycle sustainability, and policy to support risk distribution (ICF, 3 October 2023).

Then I write it as an instrument question: suggestions published for financiers include government or commercial loan guarantees like those performed by export credit agencies, plus purchase or price guarantees to support financiers with additional long-term certainty regarding project viability (ICF).

Then the volume the index has to price: by 2030 global SAF production capacity is expected to reach around 20 Mt with the project success factor applied, and HEFA refineries are likely to still dominate, accounting for about 95% of total volume.

My model then shows one mechanism, one party that absorbs the movement, and one cap on how far the formula can travel. That is the whole file, and it survives a read.

What this means for you: build the model around one mechanism, one absorbing party and one cap, then test it against the mandate, not against a price forecast.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

The premium is too uncertain to establish a reliable value, the price depends on regulatory demand and on supply combining feedstock and production costs, and a significant part of the market, long-term offtake agreements and equity stakes, is likely not covered in price reporting agency assessments (Dentons; IATA). An index describing only part of the deals actually done would not give a lender a number to rely on.

Cost-of-production is a price reporting agency assessment built from assessed feedstock prices and related costs at the refinery gate, while cost-plus forecasts feedstock, hydrogen, variable and fixed costs, CAPEX and OPEX, deducts rebates and leaves the green premium, the extra paid above the fossil reference. The cost-plus model is becoming more popular with suppliers because the risk profile favors the seller (IATA).

Under cost-plus the fluctuation of feedstock and hydrogen is passed from seller to buyer, which can represent a significant shift in pricing if feedstock market price conditions change. That is why the contract needs strong transparency provisions on fluctuating costs and a diversified feedstock mix (IATA).

With no well-established SAF pricing index, lenders will likely require a fixed-cost basis or a reference to another commodity index with which they are familiar and comfortable. For near-term supply, a conventional aviation fuel index plus an agreed premium lets the buyer keep its existing hedging practice, though that premium is often higher than under long-term offtake pricing (Dentons; IATA).

Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?

A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.

If your model is ready to be read by capital, I use investor introductions to place it in front of the right people, once the pricing mechanism and the pass-through clause are fixed on paper.

I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.

More about me·Get in touch

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related articles