We Connect Asia

SAF

Operating Performance Guarantees for SAF Plants: What Lenders Ask For

10 min read  ·  Nov 2, 2026  ·  By Alex

saf operating risk guarantees

The guarantees that decide whether a new sustainable aviation fuel plant survives its first operating years are the ones covering capacity and output, product quality and yield, utility consumption, the availability of the units the offtake (the contract under which a buyer takes the plant’s output) depends on, feedstock supply, and the credit standing of whoever signs those promises. Each needs a named guarantor and a defined remedy rather than a general comfort letter. In practice you negotiate a schedule of promises beside the loan documents and the offtake, and my parent note on SAF project risk allocation sets the frame. The SAF operating risk guarantees you accept at final investment decision, FID (final investment decision), shape both debt and revenue.

Between mechanical completion and the end of the loan tenor, disputes are rarely about the process choice. They are about which promise was written, against which test, and backed by whom. I draft that schedule alongside the EPC (engineering, procurement and construction contract) before the price is agreed.

In short

  • Where the risk sits: six operating lines, each with a named guarantor and a written remedy.
  • The core instrument: a performance guarantee, a minimum level underneath, and damages per percentage point below.
  • The evidence: one test exhibit per unit covering timing, protocol, retest rights and who pays.
  • The counterparty: licensors, contractors and equipment suppliers carry what they can show they can pay.
  • The revenue side: guarantees and offtake must cover the same volumes over the same tenor.
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

In this article

Which operating risk sits where after start-up

Once the plant runs, the operating risk splits into six lines: capacity and output, product quality and yield, utility consumption, the availability of the units the offtake depends on, feedstock supply, and the credit standing of whoever signs those promises. Each needs a named guarantor and a remedy, not a general comfort. At commissioning and operation, bankable process guarantees from the process licensors and EPC contractors are essential to progressing past that stage, and investors scrutinise initial performance because early operational issues could hinder the ability to raise additional funds (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025).

What this means for you: name the guarantor behind each of the six lines before you sign, and confirm that every remedy is money, reperformance or termination.

Performance guarantees and performance liquidated damages

Performance guarantees and performance liquidated damages, PLD (performance liquidated damages), are an essential element of most EPC contracts, especially on renewable energy projects, and they make guaranteed performance, quality and output enforceable while compensating the owner for losses when the plant misses (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). They set baseline capacity, output or efficiency expectations so owners, financiers and offtakers know the facility will run as intended and offtake volumes generated (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). It is the operating layer behind how to finance a SAF project. Most contracts include a minimum performance guarantee, the absolute lowest acceptable level: a project may carry a guarantee of 98 percent of nameplate capacity and a minimum of 93 percent, with damages a fixed sum for each fraction of a point below it, illustrated at 120,000 US dollars (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). Contractors try to cap that exposure at 5 to 25 percent of the contract price, most projects sit at 10 to 15 percent of the EPC price, and a cap rarely frees a contractor that misses the minimum guarantee, because that failure usually triggers reperformance obligations rather than damages (Husch Blackwell, May 2025).

What this means for you: read the minimum guarantee before the headline guarantee, price the damages rate against your model, and check whether the cap covers reperformance.

The testing regime: timing, retests and evidence

Testing rights are part of what you settle on the road to FID, not afterwards. Guarantees are normally measured at the substantial completion milestone, and some contracts let the contractor reach the guaranteed level by final completion through rework and retesting, so the timeline, the rework and the length of retesting must be negotiated rather than assumed, and there may be no room to reperform where a certification deadline applies (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). Testing belongs in an exhibit stating when the test begins, how long it lasts, the protocol and the reporting conditions, with parameters such as total solids, ammonia, chloride, acidity, temperature and the feedstock schedule, and a 30-day test at 98 percent uptime can set the guaranteed level (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). An initial capacity guarantee at mechanical completion gives interim compensation until substantial completion, funded through damages measured against expected merchant revenue, early generation payments at a pre-agreed rate, or insurance covering loss of revenue (Husch Blackwell, May 2025).

What this means for you: attach one test exhibit to each unit, with start date, duration, protocol, retest rights and who pays for a second run.

Who stands behind the guarantee, and for how long

Guarantees should come from whoever can carry them: where a dedicated equipment supplier is responsible for a critical component it may be the right party to give the guarantee, and if the EPC contractor buys that equipment the obligations must flow through the EPC contract, while equipment bought directly by the owner should be negotiated with the supplier (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). On the process side, sponsors should require the licence documents to contain strong performance guarantees covering the production and quality of the end-products and the consumption of utilities, alongside an IP grant that lasts for the intended life of the plant (Clifford Chance, July 2024, a source older than two years). Where the licensor also supplies equipment, does the feasibility work and takes the basic engineering and construction, the scopes blur and the guarantees blur with them, so the interface matrix matters (Clifford Chance, July 2024). Owners must align contractor guarantees with the financial model and the other project contracts, including the financing agreements, to avoid a gap in liability that falls back on the owner (Husch Blackwell, May 2025).

What this means for you: put each guarantee in the name of the party that can pay it, make the scopes explicit where one party holds several roles, and reconcile every line with the model.

Offtake, quality and revenue risk in the operating years

Market risk in this sector is price uncertainty when no fixed-price structure exists, vague or non-binding demand signals, short-term or small offtake agreements, offtaker creditworthiness and the risk of buyers or producers defaulting (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025). Investors often require at least 70 to 80 percent of annual capacity to be covered by offtake agreements, some lenders require 100 percent of the SAF produced to have reliable offtake across the loan tenor, and airline credit ratings are on average lower, so spreading default risk across several parties matters (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025). Securing a SAF offtake agreement is therefore a guarantee question as well as a commercial one: the contract should be binding rather than a memorandum of understanding and should cover the debt tenor of 8 to 14 years (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025). In a market with no established offtake marketplace, pricing benchmarks are limited and long-term pricing stays uncertain and potentially volatile (Akin Gump, undated, consulted 15 November 2026).

What this means for you: write the guarantee schedule and the offtake against the same volumes and tenor, because a plant that pays damages on one side while failing the other pays twice.

Interfaces, logistics and the operating cost base

The facilities needed to produce SAF at the anticipated scale do not currently exist, so supply chain dependencies and interfaces carry real weight in early projects, particularly for producers without a full-chain integrated solution (Akin Gump, undated, consulted 15 November 2026). Delivery adds exposure: there is no dedicated SAF pipeline infrastructure, early commercial operation dates and volumes are uncertain, and weak logistics raise the risk that the offtaker fails to take neat SAF at the point of production (Akin Gump, undated). Operating cost is exposed to competition for inputs: HEFA accounts for all SAF production today and over 80 percent of announced capacity by 2030 but is constrained by waste lipid availability and competition with renewable diesel, and competition for biomass, renewable electricity, clean hydrogen and CO2 from other users can raise costs or divert feedstocks (Renewable Carbon News with IDTechEx, November 2024, older than two years; Akin Gump, undated). The same exposure appears in e-SAF project finance, where current production costs run 4 to 10 times conventional jet fuel against 2 to 5 times for bio-SAF (Renewable Carbon News with IDTechEx, November 2024).

What this means for you: write the logistics chain and the feedstock competition into the cost base before you fix the guarantee levels, since yield guarantees are only as good as the inputs behind them.

Turning guarantees into a financeable operating case

Lenders read guarantees as the operating half of the risk allocation: they want the minimum guarantee, the damages rate, the cap, the retest window and the party behind each promise on one page, aligned with the financial model and the financing agreements (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). That page is what contracting and risk management work produces before you sign. They also want the revenue side intact, which is what offtake coverage of 70 to 80 percent of annual capacity is for (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025). Where guarantees are hard to give, structure the risk instead: a tolling model lets the facility provide refinery capacity for a fixed tolling fee while the toller supplies feedstocks and retains risk and title, and the wider set of instruments includes strategic industry investment, long-term binding offtake and green bonds (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025). Power-to-liquid (PtL) carries heavier operating exposure still, because that route has the highest capital requirements and depends on renewable electricity, electrolysis and CO2 capture (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025).

What this means for you: ask for that one page before credit approval, with every guarantee tied to a line in the model, and restructure the risk if a counterparty cannot carry the promise.

How I would run this if it were my file

I would write the guarantee schedule before signing anything: metric, guarantee level, minimum level, measurement window, retest rights, damages rate, cap, guarantor, and the evidence that guarantor can pay. I would keep one test protocol per unit, with the parameters that actually move the result written into the exhibit rather than left to practice. I check that each guarantee line matches a line in the financial model and a volume in the offtake, because an owner who aligns them avoids a liability gap falling on itself (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). I ask for a staged guarantee at mechanical completion if the offtake starts early, and I keep commissioning in mind: bankable process guarantees from licensors and EPC contractors are what carry the project past it (World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025). Where the counterparty behind a guarantee is thin, I treat the guarantee as decoration and price the risk myself.

What this means for you: build the schedule yourself, line by line, and treat any guarantee you cannot evidence as unpriced risk sitting on your own balance sheet.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

A performance guarantee is the promise about what the plant will deliver, expressed as a capacity, output, quality or efficiency level with a minimum acceptable level underneath it. Performance liquidated damages are the pre-agreed money that changes hands when the promise is missed, calculated per percentage point below the guarantee to compensate the owner for the loss or a reasonable approximation of it (Husch Blackwell, May 2025).

The exposure a contractor tries to cap sits between 5 and 25 percent of the contract price, and most projects use a cap of 10 to 15 percent of the EPC contract price. A cap of that kind generally does not cover failure to reach the minimum performance guarantee, which usually triggers reperformance obligations instead, subject to a larger overall limitation of liability (Husch Blackwell, May 2025).

Yes, and staged structures are normal. A contract may require a minimum guaranteed capacity at substantial completion while still letting the contractor reach the guaranteed level by final completion through rework and retesting, an initial capacity guarantee can be required at mechanical completion to give interim protection, and guarantees can be tied to a defined test period such as a 30-day test at 98 percent uptime (Husch Blackwell, May 2025). A certification deadline may leave no opportunity to reperform.

The two contracts have to be read together. Missing the minimum guarantee can make the contractor pay the costs of reaching it, including a replacement contractor, while the offtake still requires the volumes, so the owner should align the guarantee with the financial model and the financing agreements, use interim compensation mechanisms, and check that offtake coverage of 70 to 80 percent of annual capacity is matched by guarantees and by the credit standing of the parties who signed them (Husch Blackwell, May 2025; World Economic Forum with Kearney, February 2025).

Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?

A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.

If you want your guarantee schedule tested against what lenders and offtakers in Southeast Asia actually ask for, I use investor introductions and the contracting work that sits behind them.

I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.

More about me·Get in touch

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related articles