We Connect Asia

SAF

SAF Certificates and Scope 3 Reporting: What Counts and What Does Not

10 min read  ·  Oct 2, 2026  ·  By Alex

saf certificates scope 3

A certificate does not sit inside your physical inventory. It sits beside it, as a record of an environmental attribute attached to the sustainable aviation fuel you bought. That boundary decides whether an audit passes or fails. Book and claim lets me report SAF certificates scope 3 purchases outside the physical inventory, as support for a claim that I am contributing to decarbonizing aviation rather than a direct cut to my Scope 3 number, meaning the indirect emissions in my value chain, and the certificate only holds if it matches the fuel in my inventory, comes from activity within 12 months, never exceeds my activity volume, and is serialized and retired in a secure registry.

I write this at concept stage, before any contract exists, because the wording decides the audit result. The full term is sustainable aviation fuel certificate; from here I shorten it to SAFc, and each certificate covers one metric ton of unblended, certified fuel and its environmental attributes.

In short

  • Where it sits: Outside the physical inventory, reported separately from my targets and reduction claims.
  • Which emissions: Scope 1 for the fuel user, Scope 3 for the traveller or shipper, bought separately.
  • The mandate check: I confirm the fuel was not already used to satisfy a compliance mandate.
  • The baseline: The size of the cut depends on the fuel’s certified profile and the fossil baseline used.
  • The records: Each certificate is serialized, cancelled in a secure registry under my company’s name, and dated.
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

In this article

Where the certificate sits in your inventory

The Science Based Targets initiative published its Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 2.0 on 11 June 2026, and it takes effect on 1 February 2027. It recognizes energy and commodity certificates traded through mass balance or book-and-claim as a way to report progress against targets, subject to conditions. I read that as conditional recognition, not blanket permission, and the condition that shapes my filing is placement: targets and reduction claims rest on the physical inventory, and these certificates sit outside it.

Sitting outside does not make the certificate empty. It supports a contribution claim, meaning a statement that I am helping to fund the decarbonization of aviation, presented alongside direct action rather than as a subtraction from my reported emissions. Sylvera describes the treatment of the reported footprint itself as currently a gray area, with the Science Based Targets initiative expected to update its position.

What this means for you: I keep certificates on a separate line outside the inventory total, and I word the disclosure as a contribution to sector decarbonization, never as a cut to my own Scope 3 number.

Which of your emissions the certificate can address

I start from where my own footprint actually sits. The World Economic Forum reports that businesses often carry significant Scope 3 emissions from employees’ travel, described as category 6, and that shippers or freight forwarders can play a big role in reducing the carbon footprint of products shipped by air.

The claim split follows the physical chain. When fuel producers sell the physical sustainable aviation fuel, the vehicle operators who buy it and receive certificates claim the reduction in their direct footprint, Scope 1; logistics companies buy the value of the indirect reductions, Scope 3, and pass them on to customers. The two benefits can be purchased separately, and RMI states that SAFc is used by companies to claim reductions in both direct and indirect aviation-related emissions through book and claim, while the physical fuel is blended with conventional jet fuel to power aircraft.

What this means for you: I identify my category 6 travel first, decide whether I am buying the Scope 1 side, the Scope 3 side or both, and then match the certificate to that single line.

What the mandate overlap does to your claim

Compliance and voluntary demand compete for the same barrels, and that is where a claim quietly loses its value. IATA reports that under ReFuelEU Aviation in Europe, airlines pay up to five times more than the price of conventional jet fuel and double the market price of SAF, without guarantee of supply or consistent documentation, and that the UK SAF mandate has triggered price spikes that airlines absorb.

The rule I apply is simple: confirm before purchase that the fuel was not used to meet a compliance mandate. A certificate tied to a volume already counted against a supplier’s legal obligation does not give my claim any additionality, and I would be reporting a number the market has already delivered.

I keep the compliance record and the voluntary certificate as two separate records of the same fuel, with different owners and different disclosures.

What this means for you: I ask the supplier, in writing, which mandate the volume was booked against before I sign, and I keep that answer in the file with the certificate.

Baseline and carbon intensity decide the number

Two numbers decide the size of the claim. SAF typically cuts lifecycle emissions by around 80% compared with fossil jet fuel, but the reduction I can report depends on the fuel’s certified carbon intensity, meaning the grams of CO2e emitted per megajoule of energy across its lifecycle, and on the fossil baseline it is measured against.

That baseline is not universal. CORSIA uses 89 gCO2e/MJ, while the EU’s RED II, which ReFuelEU Aviation relies on, uses 94 gCO2e/MJ, so at the same carbon intensity the reduction looks larger against the EU baseline. Two certificates with identical fuel quality can therefore show different reductions.

The complication is that carbon intensities vary by certification scheme methodology, creating a risky accounting mismatch across certificates. With no clear direction from the Science Based Targets initiative, being conservative is the best option.

What this means for you: I record the baseline beside the carbon intensity on every row and never compare two certificates on percentage reduction alone, because the same fuel can produce two defensible numbers.

The conditions the claim must satisfy

The published integrity conditions are a pass or fail checklist. Certificates must match the fuel in my inventory, come from a relevant fuel system, be quantified conservatively, relate to activity within 12 months unless a longer period is justified, never exceed my activity volume, and be serialized and retired in a secure registry. Retirement means permanent cancellation in a registry so the same reduction cannot be claimed twice.

The order matters as much as the tests. Direct action comes first: I assess direct action where feasible, such as flying less or booking shares of physical SAF, before relying on book-and-claim certificates, and only when activity-level solutions are structurally limited, with those limits evidenced, may I move to certificates. To prevent double counting, the Scope 1 claim must be retired before the Scope 3 retirement, since a certificate can carry the airline’s Scope 1 claim, the end user’s Scope 3 claim, or both.

What this means for you: I run each certificate through this condition list before booking it, and I record why direct action was limited when I rely on certificates.

The evidence an auditor asks for

An auditor asks for evidence, not explanation, so I build the file first. The supplier or the SAFc intermediary retires the certificate on behalf of the buyer on a registry, which stops anyone else claiming the same Scope 1 or Scope 3 reduction. A registry records issuance, transfer and retirement, logging every transaction, and it is often needed to avoid double claiming and double counting.

Two practical points follow. I require retirement in my company’s name with a documented record, and I keep the EU compliance and carbon intensity file beside it, because a retirement in a supplier’s name does not evidence my claim. I also check the cycle: some suppliers have not yet registered certificates on a registry, extending the retirement by up to a month.

One caveat I state openly: the Science Based Targets initiative has said it will develop criteria for recognizing third-party frameworks, standards and programs, so no registry has its recognition yet.

What this means for you: I confirm the registry, the serial number and the retirement date in my company’s name before the deadline, and I flag any certificate whose retirement is pending.

Where the reporting breaks

I have seen three failure patterns, and all three are visible on one page of working papers.

The first and most common is a claim that exceeds my own activity volume, which the published integrity criteria forbid outright. The second is a certificate bought on fuel already counted under a compliance mandate, where the volume has already done its work for someone else. The third is a mismatch between the carbon intensities of two certification schemes carried on the same reporting line, where the percentages quietly stop being comparable.

DHL names the principles that would have caught all three: matching the transport type, preventing double counting, and independent third-party verification. None of them depends on good faith alone, and each leaves a document behind.

What this means for you: I test my own file against these three failures before anyone else does, because each one is a data problem with a data answer rather than a judgment call I can defend later, since a document beats a debate.

The routine I follow each reporting cycle

My routine runs in a fixed order. I collect the retirement record first, then the claim type, then the certification scheme and baseline, then the activity window, and I reject any row that cannot show all four.

I keep the certificates outside the physical inventory line and present them as a contribution, because that is what the published standard allows. Before I close the cycle I re-check that no volume exceeds my own activity and that no fuel was already counted under a mandate.

Then I keep one file per certificate, dated and serialized, so the answer to any audit question is a document rather than an explanation. Those four fields are also the four columns of the summary I hand over.

What this means for you: I run this routine at every reporting cycle in the same order, because a missing retirement record found late is a restatement while one found early is a line of evidence, and I never reorder the four checks.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Not on the inventory line. The certificate sits outside the physical inventory and supports a claim that I am contributing to decarbonizing aviation, while my targets and reduction claims rest on the physical inventory. Sylvera describes whether the reported footprint stays the same as currently a gray area, with the Science Based Targets initiative expected to update on it.

My employees’ travel is Scope 3 category 6, and shippers or freight forwarders can address the carbon footprint of products shipped by air. The benefits are separable: vehicle operators who receive certificates claim the Scope 1 reduction, while logistics companies buy the Scope 3 value and pass it on to customers, and DHL confirms that Scope 1 and Scope 3 benefits can be purchased separately.

Not if I want the claim to hold. I confirm before purchase that the SAF was not used to meet a compliance mandate, because a certificate attached to fuel already counted against a legal obligation does not give your claim additionality. IATA reports that mandated markets already push SAF prices to a factor of two above conventional jet fuel, so the compliance record and the voluntary certificate stay separate.

I keep the retirement record in my company’s name, the serialization in a secure registry, the claim type, the carbon intensity and baseline, and the activity window. A registry logs issuance, transfer and retirement, so those entries are what an auditor reads. I also keep the written confirmation that the fuel was not counted under a mandate.

Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?

A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.

If you are at concept stage and want a documented basis before you talk to counterparties, I make investor and buyer introductions around a file that already carries the claim type, the baseline, the registry and the activity window, so the conversation starts with evidence rather than a pitch.

I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.

More about me·Get in touch

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related articles