Home » Demand and Merchant Risk in Hydrogen Projects: What Happens Without a Firm Buyer
Demand and Merchant Risk in Hydrogen Projects: What Happens Without a Firm Buyer
10 min read · Sep 7, 2025 · By Alex
In a hydrogen, power-to-liquid and e-fuels project, demand risk is the risk that revenue rests on a market that is not there yet. The volume is announced rather than contracted, the price is exposed rather than fixed, and the buyer can wait. I call this hydrogen merchant risk, and it is the first test I run for a lender. Three questions settle it: what share of output sits under a firm contract, who the counterparty is, and what happens to the payment schedule if the market never appears. An announced number and a signed number are different instruments, and only one of them pays.
I order this article in five moves: how thin the firm demand base actually is. That carries the risk on an export project. What Asian buyers have put on paper, where transport cost enters the merchant case, and the lines I write for a lender. Every figure below is dated inside its own sentence.
In short
- Firm demand: Less than 2 Mtpa of cumulative firm offtake agreements stood in 2025, merely 5 percent of the potential production announced projects could reach by 2030.
- Export weight: Trade could carry more than 40 percent of announced 2030 volumes, but less than 8 percent of that rests on committed projects in 2026.
- Buyer side: Asian demand is written as price and volume targets rather than purchase obligations, in 2024.
- Transport: Conversion plus shipping adds cost per kilogram over long distance, as modelled in 2019.
- My test: I write the contracted share, the counterparty, the price mechanism and the policy anchor, dated 2023 and 2024.
In this article
What demand risk means in a hydrogen project
I use merchant risk for the risk that a project sells output into a market that has not formed yet. At a price it does not control. An offtake agreement is the contract in which a buyer commits to take output on stated terms. A firm contract is an offtake agreement the buyer cannot leave except after a defined default. Take-or-pay is the clause that obliges it to pay for a stated volume whether it lifts the molecule or not. An anchor buyer is the counterparty whose credit carries the rest of the demand book. In addition, the counterparty is the entity on the other side of the signature.
A final investment decision is the moment the developer commits the capital. In addition, a price mechanism is the formula that fixes what the buyer pays. An announced volume is a forecast; a contracted volume is a payment obligation.
What this means for you: count the pages of your demand book that carry a signature and a payment obligation. Treat the rest as unsold output, and hold the final investment decision until that count is real.
How thin the firm demand base actually is
The Global Hydrogen Review 2025 puts cumulative firm offtake agreements at less than 2 Mtpa, merely 5 percent of the potential production that announced projects could achieve by 2030 (2025). Uncertain demand remains a critical challenge to the sector’s viability. That is because producers need reliable buyers to justify investment at scale (2025). Only 9 percent of announced hydrogen projects worldwide have secured committed investments, against 0.5 percent in emerging economies, while 80 percent of these projects are export-oriented.
In addition, capital costs can reach 15 percent, three times the level in advanced economies (2025). The primary barrier is still the cost gap between low-emissions hydrogen and fossil-based alternatives in refining, steel, shipping and aviation (2025). I read that thin base as a pricing problem before a signing problem: without an offtake agreement that closes the gap in cash terms. A buyer signs nothing.
What this means for you: put the signed share of nameplate capacity in front of the price. That is because a lender discounts an unsigned volume to zero long before it discounts a price.
Why an export project carries the risk first
The Global Hydrogen Review 2026 shows trade underpinning more than 40 percent of announced volumes by 2030 if all projects materialise, yet less than 8 percent of that total, around 1 Mtpa in hydrogen equivalent, comes from projects that are operational. In construction or hold committed investments, against around 16 percent across the whole pipeline (2026). First shipments of low-emissions hydrogen are taking place and let producers trial logistics and certification approaches, while long-term bilateral contracts dominate, particularly for ammonia and ammonia-derived fertilisers.
In addition, hot briquetted iron gains prominence (2026). An export project carries demand risk before it carries anything else. That is because the buyer sits on the far side of a border and can wait for the next cargo. The sequence I use in building a contracted book therefore starts from the importer’s own demand policy rather than from the plant.
What this means for you: for an export project. Ask what share of the announced trade has a committed buyer behind it. That is because the rest is a shipping option the offtaker can decline when prices fall.
What Asian buyers have actually put on paper
The APERC Hydrogen Report 2024 records Japan setting a CIF price target of 30 yen per Nm3 in February 2024, with maximum annual production of 3 million tonnes by 2030, 12 million tonnes by 2040 and 20 million tonnes by 2050 at a price target of 20 yen per Nm3; ammonia demand is targeted at 3 million tonnes per year by 2030 at 15 to 20 yen per Nm3 and about 30 million tonnes per year by 2050 (2024). Also, the Malaysia roadmap of 2023 reports production of 2 million tonnes in 2030, 8 million in 2040 and 16 million in 2050, with shares of final energy consumption of 3.3 percent, 10.6 percent and 18.8 percent (2023).
APEC committed production capacity reached 4.2 million tonnes per year in 2024. With state-owned enterprises playing a major role in delivery (2024). These are targets and roadmaps, not purchase orders. I read them next to project finance in Southeast Asia when I judge how much of that demand is reachable in a debt model.
What this means for you: separate the target from the tender, because a volume a government hopes to consume by 2050 is not a volume a buyer is obliged to lift.
Where transport cost enters the merchant case
The Future of Hydrogen puts moving hydrogen as a gas by pipeline at around 1 USD per kg of H2 for about 1 500 km, counting capital and operating costs, and conversion to ammonia at around 1 USD per kg of H2. Therefore, ammonia transmitted over about 1 500 km costs around 1.5 USD per kg of H2 (2019). Below 1 500 km the pipeline stays the cheapest delivery option, while above it shipping as ammonia or an organic carrier wins, and at 2 500 km that ammonia route becomes broadly similar to hydrogen gas at around 2 USD per kg of H2 (2019). Salt caverns typically cost less than 0.6 USD per kg of H2 (2019).
That delivered cost sits on the producer’s side of the price, so distance eats the spread before the plant does. When the buyer is not obliged to take the volume it can wait. In addition, waiting costs the buyer nothing while the producer still carries conversion, freight and unsold output. The merchant case fails quietly, because every kilogram the offtaker declines has already been produced, converted and paid for.
What this means for you: put delivered cost and contracted price in the same line of the model, because without take-or-pay the freight. In addition, conversion stay on your side of the trade.
What turns a demand claim into something a lender will fund
Creating a global hydrogen market treats certification as an essential element of any trade, since certificates would carry compliance with standards and sustainability data such as carbon footprint. In addition, renewable energy content, letting a product be told apart from a less green one (2023). The same assessment reviewed eight voluntary schemes and five mandatory schemes and found no existing hydrogen certification system suitable for cross-border trade, with gaps in standards, ecolabelling and certification design (2023). It also sets out five critical elements of a workable scheme: the certification scheme, standards and certification design, governance, control and verification, and monitoring plus its business model (2023).
Certification lets consumers signal demand for cleaner product by buying hydrogen certified as low carbon or renewable (2023). A demand claim becomes fundable when the claim can be checked molecule by molecule, and that is the standard I apply when I read a demand study with a development finance institution.
What this means for you. A demand claim is fundable only when the certificate behind it can be checked. That is because an unverifiable claim is a preference rather than a contract.
What I put in front of the lender
I present the contracted share of output rather than the announced share, measured against nameplate capacity. Also, I present the counterparty and exactly what that counterparty is obliged to take under take-or-pay. I present the price mechanism and who carries the gap to the cost curve when the market moves against the producer. In addition, I present the demand policy that is already in force, since only 9 percent of announced projects worldwide hold committed investments against 0.5 percent in emerging economies (2025). I present the first shipments that are only now testing logistics and certification approaches (2026). All of it sits inside the risk allocation I prepare. Therefore, the lender can see which line is contracted, which line is exposed and which line depends on a policy that has not yet been written.
What this means for you: hand over four documents rather than one deck, the contract, the counterparty’s obligations, the price formula and the policy instrument, and let the lender price each of them separately.
The four lines I write in front of a lender
Four lines, written before the model:
- Contracted volume: the signed share of nameplate capacity, with the take-or-pay clause attached to it.
- Price floor: the floor inside the price mechanism and the party that carries the shortfall when the market falls below it.
- Certification evidence: the certificates and verification data that the buyer’s low carbon claim needs (2023).
- Policy anchor: the demand policy or public procurement that anchors the remaining volume (2024).
What this means for you: write the four lines before you write the model. That is because a developer who cannot state the contracted share, the price floor, the certification evidence. In addition, the policy anchor in one page is describing an intention rather than a project. The rule I extract is simple: fund what is contracted. Price what is exposed, and treat everything else as a scenario. I hold the final investment decision until those four lines survive a lender’s first read.
Sources
- IEA, Global Hydrogen Review 2025, Five key questions about hydrogen https://www.iea.org/reports/global-hydrogen-review-2025/five-key-questions-about-hydrogen, 2025.
- Also, IEA, Global Hydrogen Review 2026, Trade and infrastructure https://www.iea.org/reports/global-hydrogen-review-2026/trade-and-infrastructure, 2026.
- IEA, The Future of Hydrogen https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/9e3a3493-b9a6-4b7d-b499-7ca48e357561/The_Future_of_Hydrogen.pdf, 2019.
- IRENA and RMI, Creating a global hydrogen market: Certification to enable trade https://www.irena.org/-/media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publication/2023/Jan/IRENA_Creating_a_global_hydrogen_market_2023.pdf, 2023.
- Asia Pacific Energy Research Centre, APERC Hydrogen Report 2024 https://aperc.or.jp/file/2025/3/18/APERC_Hydrogen_Report_2024_final.pdf, 2025.
Frequently asked questions
What is merchant risk in a hydrogen project?
It is the risk that revenue rests on a market that is not there yet: the volume is announced rather than contracted, the price is exposed rather than fixed, and the buyer can wait. In practice it shows up as unsold output and as a repayment model that never reaches its debt service, because the revenue line was built on demand nobody was obliged to create.
Can a hydrogen project be financed without a binding offtake?
It is harder than financing a contracted project, but not impossible. Lenders ask for a contracted share of output, a credible price mechanism, a credible anchor buyer, and evidence that the demand policy or procurement behind the rest of the volume is already in force (2024). Without any of that, the project is financed on the balance sheet of its sponsors rather than on the strength of the offtake.
What do lenders look at when demand is uncertain?
Four things: the share of output under firm contract, the identity and obligations of the counterparty, the price mechanism, and the committed investment standing behind the pipeline. Only 9 percent of announced projects worldwide have secured committed investments, against 0.5 percent in emerging economies (2025). I write those four items on the first page of any demand memo I hand to a lender.
How much of the announced demand is actually contracted?
Less than 2 Mtpa of cumulative firm offtake agreements, which is merely 5 percent of the potential production that announced projects could achieve by 2030 (2025). The remainder is announced volume, and I never let announced volume stand in for contracted volume in a credit paper.
Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?
A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.
If you are preparing a demand case for a lender or a buyer. I will go through the contracted share, the counterparty, the price mechanism and the certification evidence with you. In addition, my offtake agreement support covers exactly that work.
I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.
Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia
I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial. In addition, financial partners needed to reach FID.
Related articles

Pitching a Climate Tech Company to Strategic Investors: What the Corporate Has to Believe Before It Writes a Cheque
How to pitch a climate tech company to strategic investors: the metric cluster, the readiness evidence and the ask that corporates fund.

Biomethane: What It Is, How It Is Made and Who Buys It
Biomethane is biogas cleaned to pipeline quality. I explain how it is made, how it differs from biogas and who buys it in Southeast Asia.

CO2 Sourcing for e-SAF Projects: What the Rules Allow and What the Contract Must Say
Biogenic CO2, direct air capture or industrial flue gas: which sources an e-SAF plant may use, what they cost and which contract terms make the fuel certifiable.

Operating Performance Guarantees for SAF Plants: What Lenders Ask For
Minimum guarantees, performance damages, retesting and who stands behind them: the operating guarantees a SAF plant needs to keep debt and offtake intact.

EPC and Construction Risk in SAF Plants: What a Lender Actually Tests
FEED scope, convertible EPC, performance guarantees and damages caps: the construction risk questions a SAF project must answer before financial close.

Matching Feedstock and Offtake Risk Back-to-Back in a SAF Project: How Lenders Read the Chain
Lenders do not buy a feedstock plan and an offtake plan separately. They buy the link between the two, and the link is where most SAF files break.