We Connect Asia

Hydrogen

Biogenic CO2 vs Direct Air Capture for PtL: Choosing My Carbon Source

10 min read  ·  Sep 6, 2025  ·  By Alex

ptl biogenic vs dac co2

A power-to-liquid plant needs renewable hydrogen and a stream of carbon dioxide. The carbon choice shapes more of my file than most inputs do. Biogenic CO2 is a concentrated off-gas that becomes feedstock only when I contract it. By contrast, direct air capture is a machine that pulls CO2 out of ambient air. A large-scale plant built today costs an estimated 125 to 335 USD per tonne (2022). That is why biogenic CO2 vs DAC is a single move. It fixes my cost line, my carbon intensity accounting and my contract structure at the same time. In a power-to-liquid process I turn captured CO2 and renewable hydrogen into a liquid fuel. Therefore, the carbon source decides what I can build and what I can sell.

How I compare the two sources

This article compares the two sources on three fronts: origin, capture cost and eligibility under a certification scheme. I keep them apart because a vented stream and a machine fail in different ways.

In short

  • Source: Biogenic CO2 is a vented off-gas at high concentration and atmospheric pressure; direct air capture is a machine drawing from ambient air (2021).
  • Capture cost: a near-pure fermentation stream around 20 to 30 USD per tonne of CO2, biomass flue gas 60 to 80 USD per tonne, air capture 400 to 670 USD per tonne (2023).
  • Efficiency: a local concentrated source is worth about 10 percentage points of well-to-tank efficiency over extraction from air (2016).
  • Accounting: air capture offers a small land and water footprint with assurance on permanence, while inventory guidance still lacks a method for it (2022).
  • Power contract: rare cheap hours do not help me, so I chase low median prices and low grid emissions instead (2023).
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

In this article

The two sources in plain words

Power-to-liquid makes a liquid fuel from renewable hydrogen and captured CO2. Biogenic carbon is carbon that plants absorbed and that returns to the air when the biomass is converted. An off-gas is a stream a process vents instead of using. Direct air capture is a machine that pulls CO2 out of ambient air. Carbon intensity is the life-cycle emissions per unit of energy I can prove. Bioenergy with carbon capture and storage is the capture of that biogenic CO2 for storage or utilisation.

IRENA and the Methanol Institute record in 2021 that operators vent biogenic sources to the atmosphere as off-gases. Those sources include distilleries, fermentation units, municipal solid waste and biogas units. They usually hold high CO2 concentration at atmospheric pressure. When someone captures the CO2 for storage or utilisation, the process takes the name bioenergy with carbon capture and storage.

That same 2021 record points to a net CO2 neutral methanol: CO2 obtained from the atmosphere, either directly by direct air capture or through biomass.

What this means for you: I treat the vented stream as supply I must contract. In addition, the machine as an asset I must finance. In addition, those two things move through my file on different timelines.

What each source costs to capture

Concentration mainly sets the capture cost. In the 2023 modelling I am working from, a near-pure fermentation stream costs around 20 to 30 USD per tonne of CO2. Biomass combustion flue gases sit at 10 to 20 volume percent and raise the cost to 60 to 80 USD per tonne. Direct air capture costs an estimated 400 to 670 USD per tonne. The same modelling uses 30, 80 and 400 USD per tonne for the three sources, with a 5 percent cost of capital over a 25 year economic life.

Those are estimates, not prices I have paid, and they move with concentration more than with scale. I treat biogenic CO2 as the natural pairing with biofuels production, because the stream already exists beside the plant. For moving and storing a captured stream I keep the carbon capture and storage picture in view.

What this means for you: I price my carbon source as a concentration problem first. A flue gas at 60 to 80 USD per tonne and an air stream at 400 to 670 USD belong to different business cases.

What each source does to my efficiency

The German Environment Agency study of 2016 puts the effect plainly: if a local source of concentrated CO2 such as biogas upgrading or exhaust gas streams of wood burning is available. Also, the energy efficiency of production is some 10 percentage points higher compared with production with CO2 extraction from the air.

The energy efficiencies of the pathways studied run from 38 percent to 63 percent well-to-tank. The figure depends on the combination of CO2 source and electrolyser technology. With low temperature electrolysis the efficiency runs from 38 to 41 percent with air and from 48 to 53 percent with fermentation or biogas upgrading. These are pathway figures from a study, not guaranteed values for my plant.

What this means for you: a concentrated stream buys me 10 percentage points of well-to-tank efficiency. I hold the 38 to 63 percent range as a documented result rather than a promise.

What each source does to my accounting

The IEA direct air capture report of 2022 says air-captured CO2 can serve as a climate-neutral feedstock. The products that need a carbon source range from chemicals to synthetic aviation fuels. In its Net Zero scenario producers use around 350 Mt of air-captured CO2 for synthetic fuels in 2050, a scenario value rather than a result. Direct air capture with geological storage offers a relatively small land and water footprint. It also gives a high degree of assurance on permanence and quantification. The latest IPCC inventory guidelines do not include an accounting methodology for direct air capture. The same report calls that gap a barrier to scaling investment in it.

Also, the 2021 record works in reverse for my second option. A biogenic stream must be evidenced as captured for storage or utilisation, not merely as available at the stack, before it counts in my carbon intensity accounting for a compliance scheme.

What this means for you: I write the accounting proof before I write the cost model, because an unaudited stream. In addition, an unmethodised technology both stall at the same point in my file.

What each source does to my fuel market position

The IEA e-fuels report of 2023 measures how the carbon choice bites through the load factor, the share of the year a plant actually runs at production. Its levelised cost of e-fuels starts to increase very quickly when the plant load factor drops below 40 percent. Levelised cost is the cost per unit of fuel once capital and running costs are spread over output.

At 50 USD per MWh the electricity price alone contributes 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule of finished fuel. The ambition studied in that 2023 report is a 10 percent share of e-fuels in aviation and shipping by 2030. Reverse water gas shift reactors turn CO2 into the carbon monoxide a Fischer-Tropsch front end needs. The industry must still demonstrate them at scale, and new synthesis routes from CO2 beyond Fischer-Tropsch remain to be explored. For the liquid product most often tied to this carbon I follow green methanol.

What this means for you: hold a load factor above 40 percent and the fuel cost stays inside my contracts. Below that line it climbs faster than they can absorb.

What each source does to my power contract

The 2023 analysis sets the rule. I identify electricity markets with low median wholesale prices and low grid CO2 emissions rather than chase a few low-cost hours. Also, the plant can be switched to minimum load or shut down while relying on buffer storage. At the best locations, capacity factors for renewable electricity can exceed 50 percent. The largest efficiency losses occur during electrolysis, where around 35 percent of the electrical energy goes to low temperature heat.

My carbon choice sits on top of that contract, since a machine I run. In addition, a stream I buy by tonne respond differently to a plant that can be curtailed. The rules that judge this electricity are the renewable fuel requirements for the power I buy.

What this means for you: I match the source to a power contract that tolerates minimum load, because a carbon stream I cannot feed during a curtailed hour is a cost I still carry.

What each source does to my file

The IEA Global Hydrogen Review 2026 reports capital spending on low-emissions hydrogen projects at nearly 7 billion USD in 2025. That is nearly double the 2024 level and equal to 0.7 percent of global investment in energy supply. Public finance for low-emissions hydrogen in emerging economies reached around 3.3 billion USD in government commitments by early 2026. Project-level finance reached around 650 million USD over the same period, mainly for preparation and lower financing costs.

The same 2026 review finds that hydrogen use in industry and synthetic hydrocarbons is only now moving to first-of-a-kind projects, so I take the case I put to a final investment decision with the carbon source documented rather than assumed.

What this means for you: I enter the file with my source named, priced and evidenced, because a reviewer in this market expects category one evidence from a sector still crossing out of demonstration.

How I choose

  • Concentration and contractability: I ask whether the stream is a vented off-gas that someone else controls or a machine output I own (2021).
  • Cost line: the capture estimate feeds my levelised cost, at 20 to 30 USD per tonne for a near-pure stream against 400 to 670 USD per tonne from air (2023).
  • Accounting proof: I check what my scheme demands me to evidence, captured and quantified rather than merely available (2022).
  • Power contract: I match the choice to low median prices and low grid emissions, with room to sit at minimum load (2023).

When the vented off-gas exists and can be contracted, I take it. A concentrated CO2 source is worth about 10 percentage points of well-to-tank efficiency over air capture (2016). When no stream can be secured on terms I accept, I take the machine. This carries carrye the estimate that a large-scale direct air capture plant built today sits between 125 and 335 USD per tonne (2022).

What this means for you: I choose the source that survives both my certification audit and my power contract, then defend it with concentration, cost, proof and electricity in that order.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

It is CO2 that plants absorbed and that is released when the biomass is converted, usually present as a vented off-gas at high concentration and atmospheric pressure. Those sources are normally treated as waste streams and vented, so my work starts by contracting them before they reach the stack. It becomes bioenergy with carbon capture and storage when it is captured for storage or utilisation (2021).

Capture cost estimates for a large-scale plant built today run between 125 and 335 USD per tonne, with the potential to fall below 100 USD per tonne with deployment and innovation, while a 2023 estimate for direct air capture carbon runs between 400 and 670 USD per tonne. For comparison, a 2023 estimate puts a biomass combustion flue gas at 60 to 80 USD per tonne and a near-pure fermentation stream at 20 to 30 USD per tonne (2022, 2023).

The concentrated biogenic stream. A local concentrated source is worth about 10 percentage points of well-to-tank efficiency over extraction from air, with documented pathways running from 38 to 63 percent. With low temperature electrolysis the efficiency runs from 38 to 41 percent with air and from 48 to 53 percent with fermentation or biogas upgrading (2016).

I fix stream concentration and contractability, the cost line it feeds, the accounting proof my scheme demands, and the power contract behind it, in that order. Each answer narrows the next one, so I settle them in sequence rather than in parallel (2016, 2021, 2022).

Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?

A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.

If you need this decision written up for a lender and a certification scheme, my EU compliance and carbon intensity support covers the evidence trail, the accounting proof and the questions a reviewer will ask about the stream I contract.

I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.

More about me·Get in touch

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related articles