Home » Green vs Blue Hydrogen: The Two Numbers I Put in Front of an Asian Buyer
Green vs Blue Hydrogen: The Two Numbers I Put in Front of an Asian Buyer
10 min read · Sep 19, 2025 · By Alex
I never open an industrial hydrogen comparison with a colour name. What I put in front of a refiner or an ammonia buyer is two emissions intensities, meaning the kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent released per kilogram of hydrogen produced, measured across a boundary I can write into a contract. That is the whole of my reading of green vs blue hydrogen: renewable electricity feeding electrolysis, the splitting of water with an electric current, gives 0 kg CO2 equivalent per kilogram in 2023, while natural gas with partial capture still lands between 5 and 8 kg, and no plant using a capture rate, the share of a plant’s carbon dioxide that is captured, above 90% is in operation yet. I begin with the guide that defines green hydrogen and then count.
What follows orders three things: what each route actually emits, what has actually been built, and the question I ask before any price conversation. I keep every figure dated, and I keep announced capacity separate from running capacity. The order matters more than the vocabulary.
In short
- The number I compare: emissions intensity, the kilograms of CO2 equivalent per kilogram of hydrogen, not the colour (2023).
- Renewable route: 0 kg CO2 equivalent per kilogram when the electricity is renewable (2023).
- Gas route with capture: 5 to 8 kg at a capture rate of about 60% (2023).
- Gas route with advanced capture: 0.8 to 6 kg above 90%, with no such plant running yet (2023).
- My first question: which boundary the figure covers, including upstream and midstream emissions, the gas supply and handling losses (2023).
In this article
The question I put in front of the buyer first
When a buyer tells me they want a blue offer, I ask one question: what measured number are you underwriting, and over which boundary? Emissions intensity only means something when it says where the counting starts and stops, at the plant gate or across the whole chain, and whether the electricity, the gas supply and the shipping sit inside the calculation. A number without a boundary sentence is a label, not a term.
A colour name tells me nothing about upstream methane, the gas leaked or vented while producing and moving the natural gas feedstock. In 2023 the shared finding was that colour names, and words such as sustainable, low carbon or clean, hide very different emissions levels and proved impractical as a basis for contracting decisions. Two offers wearing different labels can land on the same kilogram figure or far apart.
What this means for you: put the number and the boundary in the same sentence, and treat any offer that opens with a colour as an offer that has not been counted yet.
What the two routes actually emit
The IEA definitions report of 2023 found that colour names, and terms such as sustainable, low carbon or clean, proved impractical as a basis for contracting decisions. It gives the range: unabated fossil production can reach 27 kg CO2 equivalent per kilogram of hydrogen, the global average intensity of production in 2021 was 12 to 13 kg, and a retrofit capturing around 60% brings it down to 5 to 8 kg.
Capture rates above 90% give 0.8 to 6 kg, although no plants using these technologies are in operation yet as of 2023, and upstream and midstream emissions still account for 0.7 to 5 kg, mostly methane. In 2023, ammonia from natural gas without capture is 10 to 15 kg per kilogram of hydrogen equivalent against 20 to 27 kg from coal, and about 70% of ammonia is made from natural gas.
On the green side of the count, electrolysis powered by renewable electricity gives 0 kg CO2 equivalent per kilogram of hydrogen under the IPHE methodology in 2023, because no fuel is burned inside the boundary.
On the blue side, natural gas is turned into hydrogen by steam methane reforming, a reaction of gas with steam, and only part of the carbon dioxide is captured and stored, so the delivered figure is whatever the capture rate and the upstream methane leave behind.
What this means for you: ask for the metered intensity with its boundary in kilograms of CO2 equivalent per kilogram, because the design figure and the operating figure are not the same number.
What has actually been built
The IEA investment and innovation chapter of the Global Hydrogen Review 2026 is what I hand to a buyer who has been shown a slide of capacities. It records in 2026 that high capture rate carbon capture, utilisation and storage based hydrogen production has yet to be demonstrated, that the United States leads carbon capture based hydrogen projects, and that over 85% of investment targets existing hydrogen uses in industry and refineries or hydrogen-based fuels. Announced capacity and demonstrated capacity stay on separate lines in my file.
The step-by-step route through the production process page shows where each of those figures is born, at the reformer, at the capture unit or at the meter.
What this means for you: ask which claim in 2026 is an operating plant and which is an announcement, because a demonstration is not a plant running at that capture rate.
What the cost position does to the choice
The IEA executive summary of the Global Hydrogen Review 2026 states in 2026 that low-emissions hydrogen will stay more costly than fossil-based hydrogen in most parts of the world in the near term, except China, where renewable hydrogen could become cost competitive by 2030. Higher fossil fuel prices can significantly reduce the gap, but would need to stay high for extended periods to trigger sustained investment decisions.
The route through carbon capture and storage carries its own cost structure, and I set it against the electrolyser line. Volume matters too: low-emissions production grew 20% in 2025 to almost 1 Mt and passes 1% of global production for the first time in 2026, while new offtake agreements stood at around 1.7 Mt in 2025 with only about 20% firm.
What this means for you: price the gap you are asked to carry for the life of the contract, and ask whether the fossil benchmark behind it in 2026 is expected to stay high.
What a contract has to carry
The IEA trade and infrastructure chapter of the same Global Hydrogen Review 2026 records in 2026 that first shipments of low-emissions hydrogen are taking place and enable trials of logistics and certification, that long-term bilateral contracts dominate, particularly for ammonia and ammonia-derived fertilisers, and that around 170 ammonia and 130 methanol port terminals are in operation. Trade would cover over 40% of announced volumes by 2030 with less than 8% backed by operational, construction or committed projects.
For an Asian buyer, the 2026 cost picture in Southeast Asia sits underneath those shipping terms, because freight and liquefaction change the delivered number, so I ask which leg of the chain the quoted intensity covers.
What this means for you: write the certification scheme, the firm volume and the review points into the contract, because a headline volume and a firm commitment are different instruments in 2026.
What the buyers' own rules say
Japan’s Basic Hydrogen Strategy of 2023, METI, records supply targets of up to 3 million tonnes per year by 2030 and about 20 million tonnes per year by 2050, and that 26 countries and economies had a hydrogen strategy by 2022 after Japan filed the first one in 2017. South Korea’s vision of October 2021 targets 1 million tonne of clean hydrogen by 2030 split into 250 000 tonnes of green and 750 000 tonnes of blue, with 5.26 million tonnes per year of supply targeted by 2040.
That split tells me blue demand is planned demand rather than preference: in October 2021 the same buyer wrote 750 000 tonnes of blue against 250 000 tonnes of green by 2030.
The European rules travel with any export: a renewable fuel of non-biological origin, the European term for fuel made from renewable electricity, has to satisfy the accounting set out in the renewable fuel of non-biological origin rules wherever the molecule is finally consumed.
What this means for you: read the buyer’s national target before arguing about colour, because the split between green and blue for 2030 is already written down.
How I decide for a specific plant
- The emissions boundary I can evidence: the metered intensity in kilograms of CO2 equivalent per kilogram, with the electricity, the gas supply and the shipping named inside or outside it.
- The certification scheme my buyer’s jurisdiction accepts: a number no scheme there recognises is a number I cannot invoice against.
- The distance between my capture source and my electrolyser: the shorter the link, the fewer handling losses I have to account for.
- The price gap I am asked to carry: in 2026 low-emissions hydrogen still costs more than fossil-based hydrogen in most parts of the world, so the gap is a term of the contract.
Blue is the rational answer when the capture source is close, storage is permitted, the certificate is accepted, and the volumes needed by 2030 cannot come from electrolysis alone. The boundary question gets harder once the molecule leaves the pipe, as in power-to-x and e-fuels, where each step adds a count.
What this means for you: score the offer on those four lines in 2026 and take the route that survives the scoring, not the route with the better story.
The order I work in
In 2023, only 4% of announced low-emissions projects were under construction or had taken a final investment decision, meaning a board approval that commits the capital. In 2026, 22 Mt of announced potential could lose any chance of operating by 2030 without investment decisions by early 2027.
What this means for you: run the sequence in this order, emissions boundary first, certification second, cost gap third, price last. I never reverse it, because a price agreed before the boundary is agreed is a price agreed against an unknown number. Ask for the investment decision date first, because in 2026 the volume that will exist in 2030 depends on decisions taken by early 2027.
Sources
- IEA, Towards hydrogen definitions based on their emissions intensity https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/acc7a642-e42b-4972-8893-2f03bf0bfa03/Towardshydrogendefinitionsbasedontheiremissionsintensity.pdf, 2023.
- IEA, Global Hydrogen Review 2026, Investment and innovation https://www.iea.org/reports/global-hydrogen-review-2026/investment-and-innovation, 2026.
- IEA, Global Hydrogen Review 2026, Executive summary https://www.iea.org/reports/global-hydrogen-review-2026/executive-summary, 2026.
- IEA, Global Hydrogen Review 2026, Trade and infrastructure https://www.iea.org/reports/global-hydrogen-review-2026/trade-and-infrastructure, 2026.
- Japan METI, Basic Hydrogen Strategy https://www.meti.go.jp/shingikai/enecho/shoene_shinene/suiso_seisaku/pdf/20230606_5.pdf, 2023.
Frequently asked questions
What is the real difference between green and blue hydrogen?
The electricity and the carbon. Green uses renewable electricity and scores 0 kg CO2 equivalent per kilogram under the shared methodology, blue uses natural gas with capture and scores whatever the capture rate and the upstream methane leave behind (2023). That single difference settles most contract arguments, because the capture figure is the only part of the blue number anyone can engineer.
How much does blue hydrogen actually emit?
With capture at around 60% it lands between 5 and 8 kg CO2 equivalent per kilogram, with capture above 90% between 0.8 to 6 kg, and no plant at those high capture rates is in operation yet, while unabated fossil production can reach 27 kg (2023). So the honest 2023 comparison is 0 kg against a range whose best end has not been demonstrated.
Which one do Asian buyers prefer?
Both. One national vision of 2021 targets 250 000 tonnes of green and 750 000 tonnes of blue by 2030, and announced supply for 2030 still sits at 27 Mt against just above 6 Mt of committed and strong-potential projects (2021, 2026).
What should I ask a supplier before I sign?
The measured intensity with its boundary, the certification scheme my jurisdiction accepts, the plant’s capture performance evidence, and the review points, because only about 20% of newly signed volumes in 2025 were firm (2026). I ask for the evidence pack before I ask for the price.
Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?
A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.
If you are holding a green offer and a blue offer on the same volume, I can structure the comparison so that both figures arrive with their boundary attached. The commercial side sits in offtake agreements, where the emissions figure becomes a contractual term rather than a claim.
I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.
Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia
I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.
Related articles

Pitching a Climate Tech Company to Strategic Investors: What the Corporate Has to Believe Before It Writes a Cheque
How to pitch a climate tech company to strategic investors: the metric cluster, the readiness evidence and the ask that corporates fund.

Biomethane: What It Is, How It Is Made and Who Buys It
Biomethane is biogas cleaned to pipeline quality. I explain how it is made, how it differs from biogas and who buys it in Southeast Asia.

CO2 Sourcing for e-SAF Projects: What the Rules Allow and What the Contract Must Say
Biogenic CO2, direct air capture or industrial flue gas: which sources an e-SAF plant may use, what they cost and which contract terms make the fuel certifiable.

Operating Performance Guarantees for SAF Plants: What Lenders Ask For
Minimum guarantees, performance damages, retesting and who stands behind them: the operating guarantees a SAF plant needs to keep debt and offtake intact.

EPC and Construction Risk in SAF Plants: What a Lender Actually Tests
FEED scope, convertible EPC, performance guarantees and damages caps: the construction risk questions a SAF project must answer before financial close.

Matching Feedstock and Offtake Risk Back-to-Back in a SAF Project: How Lenders Read the Chain
Lenders do not buy a feedstock plan and an offtake plan separately. They buy the link between the two, and the link is where most SAF files break.