We Connect Asia

Hydrogen

Hydrogen vs Direct Electrification: Where the Molecule Still Wins

10 min read  ·  Sep 25, 2025  ·  By Alex

hydrogen vs electrification

When I am asked which decarbonisation route to defend, I start from the duty cycle rather than from a preference for a molecule or a wire: hydrogen beats direct electrification only where distance, refuelling time, high power demand or payload outweigh the price of the kilowatt hour. Direct electrification means running the job on an electric motor and a battery charged from a wire, and it keeps everything a plug can serve at lower system cost. The hydrogen vs electrification choice is settled on long-haul heavy trucks, shipping, aviation, high-temperature heat and ore reduction, which is where I point to green hydrogen, the route a wire cannot serve. Everything below follows that split.

Here is how I walk it: where the plug has already won on cost and manufacturing scale, where the molecule still wins on duty cycle, and what the market actually bought in the latest data. I then price the liquid route and read a certification ladder, so the comparison rests on published figures.

In short

  • Plug: Direct electrification wins wherever a wire can reach, at lower system cost for the whole site.
  • Molecule: Hydrogen wins where distance, refuelling time, high power demand and payload set the bill, not the kilowatt hour.
  • Market: Truck and bus fleets kept buying fuel cells in 2025 while fuel cell car sales fell.
  • Liquid: In 2023 figures, turning electrons into a storable liquid keeps only 40 to 60% of the electricity as fuel.
  • Test: I read the duty cycle, the infrastructure payer, and the site’s own power and water.
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

In this article

The question I am actually asked

The choice is not molecule versus wire. Hydrogen means splitting water, storing the gas or a derivative of it, then converting it back in a fuel cell or a turbine; direct electrification means an electric motor and a battery charged from a wire. I judge the two on distance, refuelling time, power density and payload, never on the colour of the molecule.

In 2019 the areas where a plug struggles were already visible: heavy-duty long-haul trucks, intercity coaches, shipping, aviation, iron and steel, chemicals and high-temperature heat. Money points the same way in 2019 figures: the capital cost of a car accounts for 70% to 95% of its total cost of ownership, meaning every cost the operator carries over the vehicle’s life, so fuel price only decides the outcome in vehicles that run a lot.

What this means for you: if the duty cycle fits inside a plug’s reach, you should not open a hydrogen case at all, because the molecule has to beat a wire that is already cheaper to install.

Where the electron has already won

An electrolyser is the device that splits water into hydrogen and oxygen using electricity, a battery reverses that chemistry to release the power again, and both share the same electrochemistry, electrolytes, membranes and key manufacturing processes. In Batteries and hydrogen technology (2020) battery progress is described as more advanced and electrolyser manufacturing as being at an earlier stage, which leaves electrolysers more room for near-term cost cuts.

In 2020 the price of lithium-ion batteries had declined sharply and the battery is around 40% of the total cost of an electric car. Global cell manufacturing capacity is around 320 GWh a year against the roughly 100 GWh needed for the 2.1 million electric cars sold in 2019, with China at around 70% of capacity against the United States 13%, Korea 7%, Europe 4% and Japan 3%. A battery electric vehicle, meaning a car driven only by a battery charged from a plug, is measured against that scale by any hydrogen equipment scale-up plan.

What this means for you: where a plug fits the duty cycle, the battery route already carries industrial volume, so a hydrogen case must win on range, refuelling time or payload.

Where the molecule still wins

The 2019 report The Future of Hydrogen puts heavy-duty long-haul at the top of the list, because that duty cycle calls for long range and high power. A fuel cell electric vehicle, meaning a truck that makes its own electricity from stored hydrogen, competes better against battery electric trucks than a car does.

Regional bus operations and heavy-duty long-distance freight face larger battery capacity, long charging times and high power requirements, which translate into payload loss, meaning the cargo an operator must drop to carry the battery, plus extra recharging infrastructure cost. The 2019 estimates put fuel cell vehicles competitive above 600 km if hydrogen is delivered below 7 USD per kg, while below 500 km the hydrogen price would have to fall below 5 USD per kg. In the same 2019 estimates, fuel costs are about half of total cost of ownership for heavy-duty trucks, and a future heavy-duty fuel cell system is estimated at 95 USD per kW at 100 000 units per year. Those are the numbers I weigh against hydrogen routes for fuels and feedstock.

What this means for you: beyond 600 km with a delivered price below 7 USD per kg, I can defend the molecule.

What the market actually bought

In 2025 fuel cell car sales fell in North America, Europe and Japan, largely outsold by lower-cost battery electric and plug-in hybrid cars, and more than 90 fuel cell vehicle models were available in 2025, about 15 times fewer than battery electric models.

Trucks moved the other way. The global stock of fuel cell trucks passed 35 000 vehicles in 2025, more than five times the end-2022 level, with more than 95% of them in China, yet China runs more than 25 times as many battery electric trucks. Fuel cell buses usually underperform their battery electric rivals on economics, through lower energy efficiency, higher fuel costs and higher purchase prices, and the exception is long distances with strict refuelling times and sustained cabin heating, such as intercity coaches.

Global Hydrogen Review 2026 adds the demand side: low-emissions hydrogen demand has grown by 60% since 2020 but still represents less than 1% of total hydrogen demand, the pool I size against renewable fuels of non-biological origin rules before I price offtake.

What this means for you: trucks and coaches with tight refuelling windows are where I expect demand, so size offtake risk before you size the electrolyser.

What the liquid route costs you

Power-to-liquid, meaning a storable liquid fuel made from electricity, water and carbon dioxide, pays an efficiency bill up front. In The Role of E-fuels in Decarbonising Transport (2023) large-scale commercial electrolysers operate at 65 to 70% efficiency on a lower heating value basis, the downstream synthesis step is 65 to 85% efficient, and overall thermal efficiency from electricity to fuels runs from 40 to 60%. In the same 2023 assessment, around 10 litres of water are needed to produce 1 kg of hydrogen through electrolysis.

The output is why anyone accepts that loss. In 2016 assessments, about 50 to 60% of what comes out of a Fischer-Tropsch reactor is already in the jet range by energy, and Fischer-Tropsch synthetic paraffinic kerosene is approved for blends of up to 50% with conventional jet fuel, which makes it a drop-in fuel, meaning it can enter an existing fuelling system without new equipment. I set that against carbon dioxide capture and storage.

What this means for you: a liquid route buys energy density with 40 to 60% efficiency from electricity to fuel, so I recommend it only where the wire cannot move the load.

What the certification ladder shows

Maturity is uneven, and the ladder shows it. The German Environment Agency readiness table of 2016 places the power-to-liquid route between 5 and 8, with carbon dioxide extraction from air as the critical element at level 6. In the same 2016 table, Fischer-Tropsch with low temperature electrolysis sits at 6, with the reverse water gas shift as its critical element, and Fischer-Tropsch with high temperature electrolysis sits at 5, with the solid oxide cell as its critical element. Each row carries its own critical element, which is where delay usually enters.

The mature corner looks different: in that 2016 table, used cooking oil in the esters and fatty acids route sits at 9. So the liquid routes are not equally mature, and the electrification side of the argument has to be read against that ladder. I apply the same reading to hydrogen cost comparisons for 2026.

What this means for you: ask which step inside the chain you are funding, because a level 5 step and a level 9 step in that 2016 ladder carry very different schedule risk.

The test I apply before I recommend a route

Before I recommend a route, I ask what the buyer can pay. In 2026 figures, across regions and across most of the industrial sector, the maximum acceptable hydrogen cost is 1 to 4 USD per kg, and that ceiling is largely driven by carbon pricing. Remove carbon pricing and the maximum acceptable cost for steel would be negative across all regions, which tells me the route is bought with a policy rather than with a margin.

Supply then has to meet that ceiling. Near term, low-emissions hydrogen stays more costly than fossil hydrogen in most of the world apart from China, where renewable hydrogen could become cost-competitive by 2030. The cost of producing hydrogen from renewable electricity could fall 30% by 2030 as renewables get cheaper and production scales up, but a forecast is not a price and I never book it as one.

What this means for you: run the route twice, once with a carbon price you can defend and once without it, and carry it forward only if your delivered cost still sits under the buyer’s ceiling.

Three lines I write in the screening note

When a screening note reaches me, I strip it to three lines, and I ask for those three lines before I open any financial model. The first states the duty cycle: distance, refuelling time and payload, because those numbers decide most of the case. The second states who pays for the infrastructure on both sides, the wire and the fuelling point, including grid connection and refuelling equipment. The third states which of the two routes the plant’s own electricity and water can support, so the answer is anchored to the site rather than to a brochure.

From those three lines the committee takes three decisions: the duty cycle threshold at which hydrogen is acceptable, the party that carries the shared infrastructure, and the evidence standard required before sanction. Anything the note cannot answer, I mark as an open risk rather than as an assumption.

What this means for you: write those three lines yourself before anyone else does, because a screening note that cannot state distance, payer and site resources cannot survive an investment committee.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Yes, but only where a battery cannot match the duty cycle. In 2019 estimates, fuel cell vehicles could be competitive above 600 km if hydrogen is delivered below 7 USD per kg, and below 500 km the price would have to fall below 5 USD per kg. In 2025 the stock of fuel cell trucks passed 35 000 vehicles while fuel cell car sales fell in three markets.

Four things: distance, refuelling time, power demand and payload, plus the price of the kilowatt hour. Where a plug can serve the duty cycle, direct electrification keeps the lower system cost. Where the load must move far or heavy, the molecule earns its place. In 2026 the maximum acceptable hydrogen cost for most industry sits at 1 to 4 USD per kg.

No. Heavy trucks, intercity coaches, iron and steel, chemicals and high-temperature heat sit on the same list, because a plug struggles with range, power and heat. Shipping and aviation simply add the longest distances and the hardest refuelling constraints.

Three questions: what the duty cycle is in distance, refuelling time and payload; who pays for the infrastructure on both sides; and what the plant’s own electricity and water can support. I also ask what delivered hydrogen cost the buyer can accept, and whether carbon pricing carries that number.

Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?

A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.

If you want a second set of eyes on this route selection work, I offer strategic partnership support for developers who must put one defensible option in front of an investment committee, from duty cycle screening through to the numbers that carry the case.

I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.

More about me·Get in touch

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related articles