We Connect Asia

Methanol

Marine Fuels Compared: Methanol, Ammonia, LNG and Biofuel on the Same Five Tests

10 min read  ·  Nov 2, 2026  ·  By Alex

marine fuels compared

No fuel wins all five tests I apply here, so the answer starts with the route, not the molecule. Methanol is a liquid at ambient temperature, stores in conventional tanks and burns in commercially available engines. The May 2023 figures put ammonia at 18.6 megajoules per kilogramme against 19.9 for methanol. In addition, it needs minus 34 degrees or pressure to store. It is lethal as a toxin before it is flammable, as the June 2023 handbook records. LNG has the infrastructure, biofuel blends need no new ship. What decides is the route, the tank space and who signs the supply contract. That is the frame I apply on the sustainable maritime fuels page. It is the door to the tests below.

I run the same five tests on every option. They are energy per kilogramme and per cubic metre, storage and handling, safety, what the regulator counts, and what a bank reads in the file. Each test has one unit and one document behind it. In addition, the four marine fuels compared here are held to the same five.

What the five tests measure

In short

  • Energy: LNG leads per kilogramme . Marine gas oil leads per cubic metre at 36.6 GJ/m3. Methanol gives 19.9 MJ/kg and 15.8 GJ/m3, per the May 2023 table.
  • Storage: Methanol stays liquid at 20 degrees Celsius. LNG needs minus 162 degrees instead, minus 34 degrees or pressure for ammonia and minus 253 degrees for hydrogen, per the same table.
  • Safety: Ammonia is lethal at 0.5 percent in air in June 2023. Its flammable range is 15 to 28 percent. methanol combustion cuts black carbon by 95 percent in May 2023.
  • Rules: The framework FAQ of 16 November 2026 puts zero and near-zero fuels at 19.0 gCO2eq/MJ against a 93.3 average.
  • Finance: In 2025, 275 alternative-fuel orders were placed, down 47 percent: 188 for LNG and 61 for methanol.
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

In this article

Five tests, not one

I apply the same five measurements to every fuel that a developer or an offtaker might put on a route. The first is energy, read twice: lower heating value, meaning the heat released per kilogramme as the fuel burns. In addition, volumetric energy density, meaning the energy held in one cubic metre of tank volume. Also, the second is storage and handling: temperature, pressure, tank type and the procedure at the manifold. The third is safety, split between flammability and toxicity. In addition, the fourth is what the regulator counts. That is greenhouse gas intensity, in grams of carbon dioxide equivalent per megajoule, measured well-to-wake from production to combustion. The fifth is what a bank reads: route, supply contract, conversion cost.

None of the five settles the choice alone. In fact, a fuel can lead one test and fail the next, and the ranking shifts with the trade.

What this means for you: fix the five tests before you fix the fuel. Therefore, a choice carried on one strong number will not survive the other four.

Energy, and the tank you have to find

The May 2023 report of the Methanol Institute puts marine gas oil at 42.7 MJ/kg and 36.6 GJ/m3. LNG gives 50 MJ/kg and 23.4 GJ/m3, methanol at 19.9 MJ/kg and 15.8 GJ/m3, liquid ammonia at 18.6 MJ/kg and 12.7 GJ/m3 and liquid hydrogen at 120 MJ/kg and 8.5 GJ/m3. In that same May 2023 report. Fuel tanks on a methanol ship take about 2.4 times the space they take on a ship burning marine gas oil.

LNG leads per kilogramme and loses per cubic metre, because a light gas needs volume that a liquid avoids. Methanol carries more energy than LNG, ammonia or hydrogen once tanks, secondary barriers and cofferdams are counted. In addition, more frequent bunkering plus tanks that need no cryogenic containment soften the penalty. In fact, tank space on a laden vessel is cargo space, and cargo space is revenue.

The supply question sits beside it. I set out where the volume comes from on how green methanol is produced.

What this means for you: size the tank first, against the round trip. In addition, the bunkering frequency you can actually book, then see what cargo the remaining volume can carry.

Temperature, pressure and handling

The same May 2023 table records the storage conditions. Marine gas oil and methanol sit at 20 degrees Celsius, LNG at minus 162 degrees, liquid ammonia at minus 34 degrees or at 20 degrees under pressure, liquid hydrogen at minus 253 degrees.

Also, the Green Shipping Programme handbook of June 2023 adds what happens when ammonia escapes. In that June 2023 handbook, ammonia expands 850 times as it goes from liquid to gas. For example, one litre spilled can form 170 cubic metres of gas at 5,000 ppm. In addition, a short exposure at 5,000 ppm is lethal.

Ambient liquid storage changes three scopes at once. The shipyard builds conventional tanks, including ballast tanks, instead of cryogenic containment or pressure vessels. In addition, the bunker barge can be a standard chemical carrier. The operation is set out on the page about methanol bunkering. The crew procedure becomes a manifold and tank procedure, with no cooling plant and no cold surfaces to manage.

What this means for you: check the bunker barge and the crew procedure as early as the tank drawing, because an ambient liquid removes a layer of equipment from the scope.

Safety, the test that stops projects

The handbook of June 2023 gives ammonia a flammability range of 15 to 28 percent in air. Its minimum ignition energy is 40 to 170 millijoules, 150 times what methane needs, and self-ignition above 651 degrees Celsius. Specifically, minimum ignition energy is the smallest spark that will light a mixture. In addition, the lower flammability limit is the bottom of that range. Also, in that June 2023 handbook, ammonia is a lethal toxin at 0.5 percent in air, below the lower limit.

So toxicity drives every leak scenario. That means gas detection, ventilation and a toxic area plan on the deck drawing, isolation. Also, the port permission that follows. The fuel side sits on the page about green ammonia.

The institute’s May 2023 report puts the lethal concentration for half a fish population at 15,400 mg/l for methanol, 79 mg/l for heavy fuel oil and 0.068 mg/l for ammonia, and has methanol combustion cutting particulate matter and black carbon by 95 percent.

What this means for you: neither number is a verdict, one sets the ventilation and gas detection. In addition, the other sets spill response, so the safety case comes before the economics.

What the regulator counts

The International Maritime Organization. The FAQ of 16 November 2026 defines the unit: greenhouse gas intensity in grams of carbon dioxide equivalent per megajoule, covering carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide across the well-to-wake chain. In that same FAQ of 16 November 2026, zero and near-zero fuels sit at 19.0 gCO2eq/MJ or less against a current average of 93.3 gCO2eq/MJ, which is 80 percent lower. Emissions and fuel sustainability must be verified independently through a certification scheme recognised under the framework. In addition, a digital registry follows the compliance state of each ship.

It is not a carbon tax on fuel: it is a performance standard enforced by flag, port and coastal states. The commercial consequence is that carbon intensity is counted upstream as well as on board. Therefore, the same molecule can pass or fail depending on how it was made. The obligation side sits on low carbon fuel mandates.

What this means for you: ask for the certified intensity figure before you ask for a price, because two deliveries of the same molecule can carry different compliance outcomes.

What a bank reads in the fuel choice

The annual orderbook figures from DNV for 2025 record 275 orders for alternative-fuelled vessels. That is down 47 percent on 2024, with 188 LNG orders taking 31 percent of gross tonnage, methanol orders down to 61 from 149 in 2024, and a container mix of about 58 percent LNG, 36 percent conventional and 6 percent methanol by tonnage.

IRENA’s 2021 pathway puts world methanol output . It labels the routes brown, grey or green by carbon intensity: bio-methanol comes from biomass gasification and e-methanol from captured carbon dioxide plus green hydrogen, and the origin of that carbon dioxide decides both sustainability and cost.

A lender reads the fuel against the route, then the supply contract, then the conversion cost, in that order, and I set out that reading on the page about fuel bankability.

What this means for you: present the route first, the signed supply term second. In addition, the conversion estimate third, because that is the order the file is read in.

How I would choose on a Southeast Asian route

I start from the trade, because the trade decides which of the five tests binds first.

For example, on a short sea container service with fixed round trips, tank space is not the binding constraint. The vessel bunkers often enough to absorb a lower energy density, and methanol fits the operating pattern without cryogenic equipment on board. Also, on a deep sea service. Range and the bunkering network decide before anything else. Also, a fuel that cannot be taken where the vessel will be is not an option at any intensity figure. On an ammonia case, I put the safety case, the toxic area plan and the port permission ahead of the economics. Any one of them unresolved stops the project at concept.

Biofuel blends sit outside these three: they ask for no new ship, and I judge them on the mandate. In addition, the certification that apply at the bunkering port.

What this means for you: name the trade first, eliminate on tank space and bunkering reach, run the safety case, and only then compare cost.

What I would put in the file before the fuel is chosen

I keep four items in the file, and I keep them before any fuel name appears.

Each item is a document, not an opinion: a port list. A general arrangement drawing, a signed safety statement and a verification certificate. As a result, anything missing at concept stage reappears later as a delay or a renegotiation.

  • The route and its bunkering points: the ports where the fuel can actually be taken, and the frequency the round trip demands.
  • The tank space available: the volume the vessel can give up without giving up the cargo that pays for it.
  • The safety case and who signs it: ventilation, detection, the toxic area plan, and the party that accepts them in writing.
  • The certified carbon intensity of the fuel offered: the figure verified through a recognised scheme, with the production route behind it.

What this means for you: an incomplete file returns a fuel recommendation that cannot be financed. Therefore, I fill these four items first and compare the fuels afterwards.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

In the table of May 2023, marine gas oil carries 36.6 GJ/m3, then LNG at 23.4 GJ/m3, methanol at 15.8 GJ/m3, liquid ammonia at 12.7 GJ/m3 and liquid hydrogen at 8.5 GJ/m3. Per kilogramme the order changes and LNG leads. On a ship, methanol still takes about 2.4 times the tank space of marine gas oil, so the cubic metre figure is a cargo question as much as a fuel question.

In June 2023, ammonia is a lethal toxin at 0.5 percent in air, far below its flammable range of 15 to 28 percent. Methanol is flammable at a low flashpoint, meaning the temperature at which its vapour can be ignited, and it is toxic to aquatic life above 1,000 mg/l as recorded in May 2023. The design consequences are not the same: one drives gas detection and ventilation, the other drives spill response.

The report of May 2023 records that methanol internal combustion engines are commercially available and that methanol stores in conventional tanks, which is why conversions exist. The handbook of June 2023 records that ammonia engines were still two to three years away at that date and that no newbuild had yet tested the class rules published in 2021.

None of the marine fuels compared wins all five. The 2025 orderbook put LNG first with 188 orders, methanol second with 61 and ammonia with limited uptake, which is a market reading rather than a technical verdict, and each fuel keeps a route where it is the workable answer.

Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?

A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.

If you are at concept stage and want the five tests run on your own route. In addition, your own fuel shortlist, I work through them with you and return one file you can take to the supplier and to the lender. Start a strategic partnership conversation.

I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.

More about me·Get in touch

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related articles