Home » Hydrogen Myths and Hype: What an Equity Investor Should Check First
Hydrogen Myths and Hype: What an Equity Investor Should Check First
10 min read · Sep 30, 2025 · By Alex
An equity investor who has to say yes or no to a ticket in a hydrogen project does not need another opinion. That is because the answer is already published. I settle every pitch with three checks: the share of low-emissions hydrogen in total demand, the volume of offtake backed by firm commitments, and the readiness level of the least mature step in the plant. Those three checks are how I clear hydrogen myths without arguing about them. In addition, the subject starts with the green hydrogen supply chain, where announced capacity. In addition, operating capacity are still two different things.
Also, in what follows I test four claims I hear in screening calls, each against a single published figure. I then give you the three checks I run before a ticket moves and the four questions I ask out loud.
In short
- Demand: Low-emissions hydrogen grew 60% since 2020 and still sits below 1% of total hydrogen demand.
- Offtake: New offtake agreements were broadly unchanged in 2025 at around 1.7 Mt, with about 20% carrying firm commitments.
- Maturity: In the 2016 table a Fischer-Tropsch route with low temperature electrolysis sits at level 6. Its critical element unproven at integrated scale.
- Announcements: Installed electrolyser capacity doubled in 2025, and almost 70% of committed capacity sits in China.
- My test: I ask who signed, which step is least mature, where the power and water come from, and what support is contracted.
In this article
The question behind the question
My answer does not rest on opinion, it rests on three checks I can point to in a published document.
By an offtake agreement I mean the contract under which a buyer commits to take the output of a plant. Also, by low-emissions hydrogen I mean hydrogen from electrolysis on low-carbon electricity, or from fossil fuels with the carbon dioxide captured and permanently stored. By a cost gap I mean the difference between that hydrogen and the fossil hydrogen a plant would otherwise buy.
The prize itself is not the debate. In 2019 hydrogen demand had grown more than threefold since 1975 and sat at around 70 Mt a year, made by consuming 6% of global natural gas and 2% of global coal. In addition, it produced around 830 Mt of CO2 a year, equal to the emissions of Indonesia. Also, in addition, the United Kingdom combined.m combined.
What this means for you: I size the market from contracted tonnes. In addition, I read the cost gap against the fossil molecule the plant already buys.
Myth one: the technology is already bankable
The claim I hear is that the plant can be built today because every part exists somewhere. Also, the 2016 maturity table from the German Environment Agency is more careful: the technological maturity of the individual process steps along power-to-liquid pathways is far more advanced than commonly assumed. However, proof of concept of an integrated value chain from renewable electricity. In addition, carbon dioxide to a readily refined product is still pending.
I define technology readiness level as how far a step has moved from idea to demonstrated operation. In that 2016 table the power-to-liquid route sits between 5 and 8. Fischer-Tropsch with low temperature electrolysis sits at 6 with the reverse water gas shift as its critical element, and used cooking oil in the esters. In addition, fatty acids route sits at 9.
A 2020 comparison is plain: electrolyser manufacturing is at an earlier stage than battery manufacturing. That is exactly why equipment cost reductions remain an expectation rather than a result. In addition, that gap sits in how a technology matures before it scales.
What this means for you: I read the readiness table before the financial model. That is because a step at level 6 cannot be underwritten as if it were at level 9.
Myth two: the market has already taken off
The claim is that the market already turned. The Global Hydrogen Review 2026 reports low-emissions hydrogen demand growth of 60% since 2020, still less than 1% of total hydrogen demand, with policies in place able to reach over 5 Mt by 2030. Far from targets announced in the early 2020s.
I define a final investment decision as the moment the owner commits the capital and the project can raise finance. On that test the pipeline has shrunk to 27 Mt by 2030 because of delays beyond 2030 and cancellations, with only around 300 ktpa of additional production reaching that decision since the previous edition. New offtake agreements were broadly unchanged in 2025 at around 1.7 Mt. In addition, only about 20% of newly signed volumes carry firm contractual commitments.
The electricity bill sets the scale: in 2019. Producing all of today’s dedicated hydrogen output of 69 Mt from electricity would require 3 600 TWh, more than the annual electricity generation of the European Union. I set that beside what carbon capture and storage has to deliver.
What this means for you: I count contracted tonnes, not announced tonnes, and I check what share carries firm commitments.
Myth three: this wave is different
The claim is that this wave is structurally different. Also, the 2020 analysis Batteries and hydrogen technology puts it bluntly: hydrogen has failed to live up to high expectations in the past. In addition, there is no cast-iron guarantee that it will in the future. Natural gas and coal still supply almost all of the roughly 70 Mt of hydrogen produced each year for fertilisers and oil refineries. That means more than 800 Mt of CO2 emissions today. Equal to the emissions of the United Kingdom and Indonesia combined.
I checked the pattern against 2019 material: several earlier waves of enthusiasm, in the 1970s around oil price shocks, in the 1990s around climate policy and carbon capture, in the 2000s around fuel cell cars at motor shows. None of them fully translated into rising sustainable investment. In addition, expectations dipped again around 2010 as battery electric vehicles advanced with cheaper initial infrastructure. The regional cost picture for 2026 tells me whether the pattern has broken.
What this means for you. I ask in one sentence what is different this time, and if the answer is only new policy, I price it as a repeat.
Myth four: announcements equal capacity
The claim is that announced capacity is capacity. In 2025 installed electrolyser capacity doubled. In addition, the capacity added that year was three times the previous record set in 2023, with China accounting for nearly three-quarters of new installations, Europe. In addition, in addition, the United States just over 10% each. just over 10% each.
Committed capacity is narrower. Almost 70% of the electrolyser capacity that has reached a final investment decision since the previous edition, around 2.4 GW, is in China, so the announced pipeline. In addition, the financed pipeline do not describe the same geography.
Price is the second half of the test. In 2026 the most industrialised buyers accept a maximum hydrogen cost of 1 to 4 USD per kg, driven largely by carbon pricing. In addition, without carbon pricing the maximum acceptable hydrogen cost for steel would be negative across all regions. That is the condition any financing plan has to meet.
What this means for you: I treat an announcement as a press release until a final investment decision is signed. In addition, I read committed geography rather than announced geography.
What the public money is actually buying
Public money is a contract, not a belief. The Future of Hydrogen, published in 2019, argued that the cost of producing hydrogen from renewable electricity could fall 30% by 2030 as renewable costs fall. In addition, hydrogen production scales up, and it named targeted, time-limited loans, guarantees. In addition, other tools as the way first movers are helped through the riskiest point of the deployment curve.
Also, in 2026 the money looks like this: a third public auction round earmarked 1.3 billion euro and awarded 1.1 billion euro to nine projects for 1.1 GW of electrolysis averaging 130 ktpa of hydrogen. More than 1 000 hydrogen policies worldwide have been announced or implemented since 2020. Demand moved the other way, with fuel cell car sales falling in 2025 in North America, Europe and Japan as lower-cost battery electric and plug-in hybrid cars outsold them.
What this means for you: I count support as contracted euros attached to named projects. In addition, I discount policy totals, because 1 000 announced measures are not 1 000 offtake agreements.
What I check before the money moves
First, efficiency. The Role of E-fuels in Decarbonising Transport, published in 2023, states that components that still have a low technical readiness level today, such as reverse water-gas shift reactors, need to be demonstrated at scale, and that the overall thermal efficiency from electricity to fuels runs from 40 to 60% with electrolysers at 65 to 70% and the downstream synthesis step at 65 to 85%.
Second, the story I am sold. Geological hydrogen means hydrogen found in natural underground accumulations rather than made in a plant. In addition, interest in it has grown sharply. By May 2026 the stock return index of listed natural hydrogen exploration companies had tripled against its 2024 base year, and start-ups in that field raised nearly 0.5 billion USD since 2023, around 15% of venture capital. My term for money placed in young companies in exchange for ownership, into hydrogen production technologies, with nearly 90% of it going to a single United States company. The resource potential remains highly uncertain and still needs to be validated by drilling. I set that against the regional investment picture.
What this means for you: I fund demonstrated steps and watch speculative ones. In addition, a tripling share price is not a drilling result.
The four questions I ask out loud
I ask four questions, in this order.
Who has signed a firm offtake, and for how many years? A signature with a volume and a term is different from a memorandum, and I want the years written down.
Which step of the plant carries the lowest readiness level? If that step sits at 6 while the rest sits at 9, the schedule and the contingency both belong to the level 6 step.
Where do the electricity and the water come from in the worst month? A plant sized for an average month fails in the dry one, and I ask for that month by name.
What public support is contracted rather than announced? Contracted euros with conditions attached count, announced programmes do not.
What this means for you: I write these four answers on one page before I value anything, and if one answer is missing I stop there.
Sources
- IEA, The Future of Hydrogen https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/9e3a3493-b9a6-4b7d-b499-7ca48e357561/The_Future_of_Hydrogen.pdf, 2019.
- Also, IEA, Global Hydrogen Review 2026 https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/af4b6218-0311-4963-91ab-903cb18ca0ca/GlobalHydrogenReview2026.pdf, 2026.
- IEA, The Role of E-fuels in Decarbonising Transport https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/9e0c82d4-06d2-496b-9542-f184ba803645/TheRoleofE-fuelsinDecarbonisingTransport.pdf, 2023.
- German Environment Agency, Power-to-Liquids: Potentials and Perspectives for the Future Supply of Renewable Aviation Fuel https://www.bauhaus-luftfahrt.net/fileadmin/user_upload/Publikationen/161005_uba_hintergrund_ptl_barrierrefrei.pdf, 2016.
- IEA, Batteries and hydrogen technology: keys for a clean energy future https://www.iea.org/articles/batteries-and-hydrogen-technology-keys-for-a-clean-energy-future, 2020.
Frequently asked questions
Is hydrogen a bubble or a real market?
I see a large conventional market and a small clean one. Around 70 Mt a year is still made from natural gas and coal for fertilisers and oil refineries, while low-emissions hydrogen was still below 1% of total demand in 2026. A bubble forms when an announced number is mistaken for a contracted number, and separating the two is the first job I do.
How do I tell an announced project from a committed one?
I look for three documents: a signed final investment decision, an offtake agreement carrying firm contractual commitments, and a closed financing. Announced volumes and contracted volumes are counted differently, and in 2025 new offtake agreements stood at around 1.7 Mt with only about 20% of newly signed volumes carrying firm commitments. Without those papers the project stays on the announced list.
Should I believe the cost curve projections?
I treat a projected cost decline as a scenario value, never as a current fact. I ask which assumption does the work: cheaper renewable electricity, higher utilisation, or cheaper equipment. Where a step of the plant still sits at a low readiness level, the cost curve follows the demonstration rather than leading it.
What is geological hydrogen and should I fund it?
Geological hydrogen means hydrogen found in natural underground accumulations rather than produced in a plant. Interest rose sharply, and by May 2026 a listed exploration index had tripled against its 2024 base year, yet the resource potential remains highly uncertain and still needs to be validated by drilling. I fund drilling data before I fund a share price.
Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?
A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.
If a project passes these four checks, I arrange investor introductions to investors who ask the same questions before they commit, and I say. Therefore, plainly when it does not pass. I work with owners who can answer all four in one sitting.
I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. Moreover, I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.nd facilitator.
Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia
I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial. In addition, financial partners needed to reach FID.
Related articles

Pitching a Climate Tech Company to Strategic Investors: What the Corporate Has to Believe Before It Writes a Cheque
How to pitch a climate tech company to strategic investors: the metric cluster, the readiness evidence and the ask that corporates fund.

Biomethane: What It Is, How It Is Made and Who Buys It
Biomethane is biogas cleaned to pipeline quality. I explain how it is made, how it differs from biogas and who buys it in Southeast Asia.

CO2 Sourcing for e-SAF Projects: What the Rules Allow and What the Contract Must Say
Biogenic CO2, direct air capture or industrial flue gas: which sources an e-SAF plant may use, what they cost and which contract terms make the fuel certifiable.

Operating Performance Guarantees for SAF Plants: What Lenders Ask For
Minimum guarantees, performance damages, retesting and who stands behind them: the operating guarantees a SAF plant needs to keep debt and offtake intact.

EPC and Construction Risk in SAF Plants: What a Lender Actually Tests
FEED scope, convertible EPC, performance guarantees and damages caps: the construction risk questions a SAF project must answer before financial close.

Matching Feedstock and Offtake Risk Back-to-Back in a SAF Project: How Lenders Read the Chain
Lenders do not buy a feedstock plan and an offtake plan separately. They buy the link between the two, and the link is where most SAF files break.