Home » PtL Cost Competitiveness and the Green Premium: Who Pays the Gap
PtL Cost Competitiveness and the Green Premium: Who Pays the Gap
10 min read · Sep 9, 2025 · By Alex
Power-to-liquid turns renewable hydrogen plus captured CO2 into a liquid fuel that needs no engine change, and I keep the full explainer on power-to-liquid as my physical baseline. The green premium, defined as the extra cost over the fossil equivalent, is the only thing standing between that fuel and a buyer. I do not read ptl cost competitiveness as one number: I read it as five separate lines, and the largest is electricity, because at 50 USD per MWh in 2023 modelling the power price alone already adds 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule of finished fuel before any capital spending. I walk those five lines below, in the order I would check them.
I will show where the premium sits in the cost stack, what a blending mandate and a public premium each cover, and which apparent saving I refuse to book. The test is whether a number is a price, a scenario or a 2016 estimate.
In short
- Electricity: at 50 USD per MWh in 2023, power alone adds 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule of finished fuel.
- Load factor: the share of the year the plant runs; below 40 percent in 2023 the levelised cost climbs fast.
- CO2 source: 20 to 30 USD per tonne for fermentation in 2023, 400 to 670 USD per tonne for direct air capture in 2023.
- Compliance: an aviation shortfall in the 2024 rules is owed in the next reporting period, on top of that period’s obligation.
- Subsidy: a fixed premium per kilogram of hydrogen covers part of the gap while it runs.
In this article
Where the premium actually sits
The IEA e-fuels report of 2023 puts the electricity line first: at 50 USD per MWh the power price alone contributes 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule of finished fuel, which is 1,000 to 1,500 USD per tonne of oil equivalent in 2023, before any capital spending or consumable. Load factor is the share of the year the plant actually runs, and levelised cost spreads total cost over the energy sold, so fewer running hours pay the capital over fewer gigajoules. In that same 2023 modelling the levelised cost rises very quickly once the electrolyser load factor drops below 40 percent, and overall thermal efficiency from electricity to fuel ranges from 40 to 60 percent.
What this means for you: before I model anything else I fix the power price and the hours the plant runs, because those two lines set the floor and every later saving sits on top of them.
What the inputs cost before the plant is built
In 2023 modelling, capturing CO2 from a high concentration fermentation stream costs around 20 to 30 USD per tonne, biomass combustion fluegas at 10 to 20 volume percent costs 60 to 80 USD per tonne, and direct air capture, which means pulling CO2 out of ambient air, is estimated at 400 to 670 USD per tonne in 2023. The same 2023 modelling uses 30, 80 and 400 USD per tonne for those three sources, a 5 percent cost of capital and a 25 year economic life, with electrolysers at 800 and 2,000 USD per kilowatt electric. For the hydrogen line I use green hydrogen cost modelling for 2026 in Southeast Asia.
What this means for you: I price the carbon source before I price the fuel, because the spread from 20 to 30 USD per tonne to 400 to 670 USD per tonne in 2023 can erase a business case on its own.
What the mandate actually pays for
The aviation blending rule does not buy fuel, it forces volume. Under the ReFuelEU Aviation rules as set out by IATA in September 2024, minimum SAF shares go from 2 percent in 2025 to 6 percent in 2030, then 20 percent in 2035, 34 percent in 2040, 42 percent in 2045 and 70 percent in 2050, with a synthetic sub-share of 1.2 percent on average over 2030 to 2031 rising to 35 percent from 2050. There is no buy-out for fuel suppliers: a shortfall is still owed in the next reporting period, on top of that period’s obligation. So the mandate creates demand for a power-to-liquid fuel without ever naming a price it will pay.
What this means for you: I treat the mandate as a volume obligation with a debt attached, not as a revenue line, and I model the synthetic share separately from the 1.2 percent in 2030 and 2031.
What the old cost table still shows
A 2016 estimate is a ratio, not a price, and I read it that way. With low temperature electrolysis, the German Environment Agency study of 2016 costed the methanol route at 39.8 EUR per gigajoule using CO2 captured from air against 28.0 EUR per gigajoule with a concentrated source, and the Fischer-Tropsch route at 42.7 against 31.3 EUR per gigajoule. Converted to tonne terms in the same 2016 study that is 1,719 and 1,206 EUR per tonne for methanol and 1,841 and 1,352 EUR per tonne for Fischer-Tropsch. Carbon dioxide supply alone was 359 million EUR with air capture against 45 million EUR with a concentrated source in 2016, and total investment was 602 million EUR against 288 million EUR in 2016.
What this means for you: I keep this table as a ratio, not a price, because it shows that a concentrated CO2 source cut the 2016 investment from 602 million EUR to 288 million EUR, and ratios survive where prices do not.
What the electricity rules add to the bill
Under the rules analysed by Stibbe, monthly correlation holds until 31 December 2029 and hourly correlation applies from 1 January 2030. Any renewable installation behind a power purchase agreement must have come into operation no more than 36 months before the electrolyser and must not have received operating or investment aid. A bidding zone is the area in which electricity is priced together, and the geographic test sits there. Installations in operation before 1 January 2028 keep the additionality exemption only until 1 January 2038. In late March 2026 the energy ministries of four member states and one state secretary warned in a joint letter that investment decisions are being delayed and long-term offtake agreements are failing to materialise. The detail sits in the RFNBO rules explained.
What this means for you: I price the sourcing rules as an extra cost of compliance, because hourly matching from 1 January 2030 changes which hours I can buy, not only what I pay for them.
Where public money narrows the gap
The European Hydrogen Bank, run by the European Commission, awards a fixed premium, which is a set payment in EUR per kilogram of verified and certified RFNBO hydrogen that does not move with the fuel price. Its third auction, held between 4 December 2025 and 19 February 2026, selected 13 projects for more than 1.2 billion EUR across 8 European Economic Area countries, from 58 bids, oversubscribed more than 6 times a 1.3 billion EUR budget. Capital spending on low-emissions hydrogen reached nearly 7 billion USD in 2025, equal to 0.7 percent of global investment in energy supply. Europe holds less than 20 percent of committed electrolysis capacity but 45 percent of estimated investment, which means higher capital expenditure per unit of capacity, in the IEA Global Hydrogen Review 2026. I use this in power-to-liquid investing and FID.
What this means for you: I treat a fixed premium as a bridge with an end date, because it lowers the cost of hydrogen for the years it runs while the electricity line and the capital bill stay put.
How I read a cost line in a model
A 2021 comparison from IRENA and the Methanol Institute gives me a yardstick: fossil methanol costs 100 to 250 USD per tonne, bio-methanol 320 to 770 USD per tonne with feedstock up to 6 USD per gigajoule and 220 to 560 USD per tonne with process improvements, and renewable methanol can stay twice the fossil price. In 2021 less than 0.2 Mt of renewable methanol is produced each year, and replacing a 2,500 tonne per day conventional plant would need an electrolyser in the gigawatt range. I carry that yardstick into low carbon fuels investment work.
- Electricity and load factor: the power price sets the base line, the hours run decide the capital per gigajoule.
- CO2 source: 20 to 30 USD per tonne for fermentation in 2023 against 400 to 670 USD per tonne for direct air capture in 2023.
- Premium coverage: a fixed premium in EUR per kilogram covers part of the gap while it runs.
What this means for you: I read every cost line against that yardstick, and I ask first which of the three lines is actually moving, rather than which one is easiest to quote.
The order I work in
- Electricity: at 50 USD per MWh in 2023 modelling the power price alone adds 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule of finished fuel.
- Load factor: what the assumed hours do to the levelised cost once the electrolyser drops below 40 percent in 2023.
- CO2 source: what concentration does to the feed cost, from 20 to 30 USD per tonne in 2023 for fermentation to 400 to 670 USD per tonne in 2023 for direct air capture.
- Public premium: what a fixed premium in EUR per kilogram covers, and what it leaves on the table.
I check the electricity line first because it is the largest and the least negotiable, then the load factor, then the CO2 source, and only then the premium. If those four hold in that order I call the cost competitive, and if they do not I stop and reprice. Nothing else in the model is worth reading before those four are settled.
What this means for you: run the four in that sequence and you will know within one pass whether a power-to-liquid fuel can compete, or whether the gap is still wider than any premium on offer.
Sources
- IEA, The Role of E-fuels in Decarbonising Transport https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/9e0c82d4-06d2-496b-9542-f184ba803645/TheRoleofE-fuelsinDecarbonisingTransport.pdf, 2023.
- Stibbe, Renewable hydrogen in the EU: a framework under pressure https://www.stibbe.com/publications-and-insights/renewable-hydrogen-in-the-eu-a-framework-under-pressure.
- IATA, ReFuelEU Aviation Handbook https://www.iata.org/contentassets/d13875e9ed784f75bac90f000760e998/refuel-eu-aviation-handbook.pdf, September 2024.
- IEA, Global Hydrogen Review 2026, Investment and innovation https://www.iea.org/reports/global-hydrogen-review-2026/investment-and-innovation, 2026.
- European Commission, European Hydrogen Bank https://energy.ec.europa.eu/topics/eus-energy-system/hydrogen/european-hydrogen-bank_en.
- German Environment Agency (UBA), LBST and Bauhaus Luftfahrt, Power-to-Liquids: Potentials and Perspectives for the Future Supply of Renewable Aviation Fuel https://www.bauhaus-luftfahrt.net/fileadmin/user_upload/Publikationen/161005_uba_hintergrund_ptl_barrierrefrei.pdf, 2016.
- IRENA and Methanol Institute, Innovation Outlook: Renewable Methanol https://www.irena.org/-/media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publication/2021/Jan/IRENA_Innovation_Renewable_Methanol_2021.pdf, 2021.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a power-to-liquid fuel cost competitive?
Five lines together: the electricity price, the load factor, the CO2 source, the cost of meeting the electricity sourcing rules, and a fixed premium of public money that covers part of the gap for the years it runs. In 2023 modelling the power price alone adds 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule at 50 USD per MWh, and in 2026 the third auction selected 13 projects for more than 1.2 billion EUR.
Why does the electricity price dominate the cost?
Because at 50 USD per MWh it already contributes 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule of finished fuel before any capital spending in 2023 modelling, and the levelised cost climbs fast once the electrolyser load factor falls below 40 percent in 2023.
Does a public subsidy close the gap on its own?
It narrows the gap only while the premium runs. The third auction, closed on 19 February 2026, selected 13 projects for more than 1.2 billion EUR paid as a fixed premium in EUR per kilogram of verified and certified hydrogen, while the electricity price alone still contributes 25 to 35 USD per gigajoule of finished fuel at 50 USD per MWh in 2023.
Which single assumption moves the cost the most?
The load factor, because the levelised cost rises very quickly below 40 percent in 2023, while a concentrated CO2 source was worth about 10 percentage points of well-to-tank efficiency in the 2016 table. Hours decide how much capital lands in each gigajoule, so I settle them first.
Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?
A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.
If you are weighing a power-to-liquid fuel against an alternative, I can run these five lines through a single model and show which one decides the case. That work sits in feasibility and financial model support.
I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.
Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia
I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial and financial partners needed to reach FID.
Related articles

Pitching a Climate Tech Company to Strategic Investors: What the Corporate Has to Believe Before It Writes a Cheque
How to pitch a climate tech company to strategic investors: the metric cluster, the readiness evidence and the ask that corporates fund.

Biomethane: What It Is, How It Is Made and Who Buys It
Biomethane is biogas cleaned to pipeline quality. I explain how it is made, how it differs from biogas and who buys it in Southeast Asia.

CO2 Sourcing for e-SAF Projects: What the Rules Allow and What the Contract Must Say
Biogenic CO2, direct air capture or industrial flue gas: which sources an e-SAF plant may use, what they cost and which contract terms make the fuel certifiable.

Operating Performance Guarantees for SAF Plants: What Lenders Ask For
Minimum guarantees, performance damages, retesting and who stands behind them: the operating guarantees a SAF plant needs to keep debt and offtake intact.

EPC and Construction Risk in SAF Plants: What a Lender Actually Tests
FEED scope, convertible EPC, performance guarantees and damages caps: the construction risk questions a SAF project must answer before financial close.

Matching Feedstock and Offtake Risk Back-to-Back in a SAF Project: How Lenders Read the Chain
Lenders do not buy a feedstock plan and an offtake plan separately. They buy the link between the two, and the link is where most SAF files break.