We Connect Asia

Hydrogen

PtL Technology Pathways: How I Choose Between Fischer-Tropsch and Methanol

10 min read  ·  Sep 22, 2025  ·  By Alex

ptl technology pathways

When I pick a conversion route for liquid fuel made from renewable electricity, the answer is short. Two production routes both work, Fischer-Tropsch and methanol. Power-to-liquid means a fuel synthesised from renewable electricity, water and captured carbon dioxide instead of crude oil. In addition, Fischer-Tropsch synthesis builds hydrocarbon chains from carbon monoxide and hydrogen. I decide between the ptl technology pathways on four things: the product approval my buyer needs; well-to-tank efficiency, the share of input electricity reaching the tank. That runs from 38 to 63 percent on the CO2 source and the electrolyser, the unit that splits water into hydrogen; the maturity of the weakest step; and where the CO2 comes from. I also need a drop-in fuel, one that needs no change to engine or fuelling. In addition, the wider frame for this argument is power-to-liquid.

This article orders the two routes, states what actually separates them, and gives the order in which I make the choice. I take the technology comparison first, then the carbon source, then money, infrastructure and demand. In addition, I close with the sequence I apply to a live project.

In short

  • Two routes: Fischer-Tropsch synthesis and methanol synthesis, both fed by renewable hydrogen and captured CO2 (2016).
  • Efficiency: well-to-tank runs from 38 to 63 percent (2016) depending on the CO2 source and the electrolyser.
  • Approval: a 50 percent Fischer-Tropsch jet blend is allowed, while the methanol route is still pending approval (2016).
  • Carbon: less than 0.2 Mt of renewable methanol is made a year against 98 Mt of mostly fossil methanol (2021).
  • My order: buyer’s obligation, evidenced CO2 source, weakest step, efficiency kept after conversion (2016, 2026).
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

In this article

What the choice actually decides

The route I pick settles four things before any engineering is drawn. It settles the product that leaves the plant and the standard my buyer has to satisfy. Also, it settles the CO2 source I can defend for the life of the plant, since a concentrated source and direct air capture, which pulls carbon dioxide out of ambient air, are not interchangeable. It settles how much of the input electricity I keep as fuel, and it settles which steps of the chain are proven and which are still only being demonstrated (2016).

What this means for you: you settle the route before you commission the concept study, not after it, because the concept study inherits the product specification, the CO2 sourcing and the efficiency target from this decision. A concept study cannot choose for me, it can only price what I have already chosen. Paying for engineering detail on an unsettled route buys work I would only redo, so I fix the four choices first and then brief the study against them.

The two routes and what separates them

The German Environment Agency study of 2016 records two production routes, Fischer-Tropsch and methanol, whose energy conversion efficiencies differ negligibly. Across the configurations it studied, well-to-tank efficiency runs from 38 to 63 percent (2016). Two choices drive that spread: a concentrated CO2 source adds about 10 percentage points over direct air capture. In addition, high-temperature electrolysis with synthesis heat recovery adds another 10 points over low-temperature electrolysis (2016).

Technology readiness level, my 0 to 9 scale for how far a step has been proven, reads 6 for Fischer-Tropsch with low-temperature electrolysis and 5 with high-temperature, 8 for the methanol route with low-temperature and 5 with high-temperature, while reverse water gas shift, the reaction that turns CO2 into the carbon monoxide the Fischer-Tropsch route needs, sits at 6 and direct air capture at 6 (2016).

What this means for you: on the product side the ASTM jet fuel standard already allows a 50 percent blend of Fischer-Tropsch synthetic fuel, while no jet fuel has yet been produced through the methanol route. In addition, its approval is pending (2016). I settle that gap before anything else, and it is the first line of my case to final investment decision.

What the methanol route means for my carbon source

The IRENA and Methanol Institute outlook of 2021 records around 98 Mt of methanol produced each year, nearly all from fossil fuels, with life-cycle emissions near 0.3 Gt CO2 a year, about 10 percent of chemical sector emissions. On current trends output could reach 500 Mt a year by 2050 and release 1.5 Gt CO2 a year if it stays fossil (2021).

Renewable methanol is the thin edge: less than 0.2 Mt is produced a year, mostly bio-methanol, and e-methanol comes from CO2 captured from renewable sources such as bioenergy with carbon capture and storage or direct air capture plus green hydrogen, through a one-step catalytic process (2021). Fossil methanol costs 100 to 250 USD per tonne, and bio-methanol can cost up to twice that (2021).

What this means for you. For me the carbon source is the whole question, so I test my carbon capture case before I test the reactor. In addition, I will not carry a methanol route forward without a renewable CO2 source I can evidence for the life of the plant (2021).

What the money has decided so far

The IEA Global Hydrogen Review 2026, in its Investment and innovation chapter, records that hydrogen use in industry. In addition, synthetic hydrocarbons is only now moving to first-of-a-kind projects, more slowly than more modular end-use sectors such as transport (2026).

Capital spending on low-emissions hydrogen reached nearly 7 billion USD in 2025, almost double 2024 and equal to 0.7 percent of global energy supply investment, and over 85 percent of it targets existing hydrogen uses in industry. In addition, refineries or hydrogen-based fuels (2026). Venture capital for hydrogen fell from a 13 percent peak of energy venture capital in 2023 to 4 percent in 2025, with aviation taking almost 25 percent of it (2026).

What this means for you. The capital is still following existing uses rather than a new fuel, so I size my green hydrogen supply against that 85 percent rather than against a fuel market that does not exist yet (2026). Also, the fall to 4 percent of energy venture capital in 2025 tells me how long the wait may be (2026).

What the infrastructure already rewards

The IEA Global Hydrogen Review 2026, in its Trade and infrastructure chapter, records around 170 ammonia and 130 methanol port terminals in operation, with more methanol infrastructure under construction, mainly linked to bunkering (2026).

Where pure hydrogen is required at the point of use, shipping implies minimum costs of around 2 USD per kilogram. In addition, energy use above 10 kWh per kilogram, over 30 percent of hydrogen’s energy content (2026). Announced hydrogen pipelines exceed 40 000 km by 2035, with only 9 percent of that length operational or committed (2026).

What this means for you: the liquid infrastructure that already runs is what I count on when the product has to move. Therefore, I ask first whether my buyer takes sustainable aviation fuel or a chemical (2026). Methanol terminals already in operation, with more under construction, are a real argument for the methanol route, while a pipeline figure that is 9 percent committed is not an argument for anything (2026).

What the demand side says about the product

The IEA Global Hydrogen Review 2026, in its Executive summary, records that around 80 percent of production with strong potential to 2030 targets chemicals, refining and low-emissions fuels (2026). Low-emissions hydrogen production grew 20 percent in 2025 to almost 1 Mt and passes 1 percent of global production for the first time in 2026 (2026).

New offtake agreements stood at around 1.7 Mt in 2025, with only about 20 percent of newly signed volumes firm. In addition, low-emissions hydrogen will stay more costly than fossil-based production in most parts of the near term except China (2026).

What this means for you: my buyer’s obligation sits inside that demand picture. Whether it comes from the RFNBO rules that bind my buyer or from a jet standard, so I ask for the firm volume in writing before I fix the route (2026). An agreement that is not firm is not a demand case. In addition, a cost gap that stays open in most regions is a cost I have to carry in my numbers (2026).

How I decide for a specific project

I run four tests in a fixed order, on the specific project rather than on the technology in the abstract.

  • Buyer’s obligation: the product my buyer is obliged to buy and the standard that product has to satisfy (2016).
  • Carbon source: the CO2 source I can evidence for the whole life of the plant (2016).
  • Weakest step: the least mature step in my chain, read on the 0 to 9 readiness scale (2016).
  • Efficiency kept: the well-to-tank efficiency I still have after every conversion loss (2016).

What this means for you. The methanol route wins for me when my buyer needs methanol or a chemical feedstock rather than jet fuel, when my CO2 source is a concentrated stream I can evidence, and when low-temperature electrolysis leaves the weakest step at 8 instead of 5 (2016). Also, the pending jet approval then stops mattering, because I am not selling jet fuel (2016).

The order I work in

Announced production of low-emissions hydrogen for 2030 stands at 27 Mt against just above 6 Mt of committed and strong-potential projects (2026), and around 40 percent of that potential depends on decisions taken before the beginning of 2027. In the regions where it sits (2026).

What this means for you: I fix the product first, then the CO2 source, then the weakest step, then the efficiency I can live with, and only then do I commission the concept study. Those four sit in the order a buyer, a regulator and an engineer would each check them (2016). The wider window closes before the beginning of 2027 (2026), so I do not let the sequence drift.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

There are two main routes: Fischer-Tropsch synthesis and methanol synthesis, both fed by renewable hydrogen and captured CO2. Where carbon monoxide is required, reverse water gas shift or co-electrolysis supplies it, and the methanol route accepts CO2 directly (2016).

Neither, in any way that decides a project. The configurations studied run from 38 to 63 percent well-to-tank depending on the CO2 source and the electrolyser, with a concentrated CO2 source worth about 10 percentage points and high-temperature electrolysis with heat recovery about 10 more (2016).

Partly. The standard already allows a 50 percent blend of Fischer-Tropsch synthetic fuel, while no jet fuel has yet been produced through the methanol route and its approval is still pending (2016). I treat pending as pending, and I do not sign a methanol jet offtake on it (2016).

I go in this order: the product my buyer is obliged to buy, the CO2 source I can evidence, the weakest step in my chain by readiness level, and the efficiency I keep after conversion (2016, 2026). The first two are contractual, the third is technical and the fourth is what survives them (2016). Only after those four do I pay for engineering detail.

Not sure your project would survive a credit conversation?

A short call is usually enough to see where your project stands.

If you want a second check on that sequence before the concept study is commissioned, I run technology maturity. In addition, scale up work on each step of the chain, and I write up what the readiness levels imply for the route you are about to pick.

I do not provide investment advice or arrange investments. I act as a strategic advisor and facilitator.

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

Alex, Founder of WeConnect Asia

I help low-carbon fuel and carbon removal project developers in Southeast Asia secure the commercial. In addition, financial partners needed to reach FID.

More about me·Get in touch

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related articles